Bills–Patriots rivalry

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Buffalo Bills–New England Patriots
First meetingSeptember 23, 1960
Bills 13, Patriots 0
Latest meetingDecember 23, 2018
Patriots 24, Bills 12
Next meetingSeptember 29, 2019
Meetings total117 meetings[1]
All-time seriesPatriots, 73–43–1
Postseason resultsPatriots, 1–0
Last meeting
December 28, 1963, Patriots 26–8
Largest victoryPatriots, 56–10 (2007)
Current win streakPatriots, 5
Playoff and Championship Success
AFL Championships (2)
  • Bills (2) – 1964, 1965
  • Patriots (0) – none

Super Bowl Championships (6)

Super Bowl Appearances (15)

AFL Eastern Division Championships (4) (1960–1969)

AFC East Divisional Championships (27) (1970–present)

AFC Wild Card Berths (11) (1970—present)

The Bills–Patriots rivalry is a professional American football rivalry between the Buffalo Bills and the New England Patriots. Both teams are members of the East division of the American Football Conference (AFC) in the National Football League (NFL). The teams play two scheduled games each season as a result. The series debuted in 1960 as part of the American Football League (AFL). As of October 2016, the Patriots lead the series 70–43–1; the two clubs have combined for thirteen AFL/AFC championships. Six Bills players, coach Marv Levy, and team founder Ralph Wilson are enshrined in the Pro Football Hall of Fame, while five Patriots players and coach Bill Parcells are presently enshrined in the Hall of Fame.

The series has been notable for its recent lopsidedness, especially during the career of Patriots quarterback Tom Brady, who presently holds a record of 29–3 against the Bills with 68 touchdowns and 21 interceptions and has won more games in New Era Field than any quarterback for Buffalo since 2001.[2][3] Prior to Brady's career, Bills Hall of Famer Jim Kelly compiled a 12–8 career record against the Patriots with 29 touchdowns and 28 interceptions;[4] O.J. Simpson compiled a 10–4 record against the Patriots with 14 rushing touchdowns and three touchdown catches.[5]



The Bills and Patriots played for the first time in a preseason game during the first season of the American Football League on July 30, 1960. The game was played at War Memorial Stadium in Buffalo, and the Patriots won the game 28–7.[6] The teams met for their first regular season game during Week 3 of the inaugural season of the American Football League in 1960. The game was played at Nickerson Field at Boston University on Friday, September 23, 1960. The Bills scored a touchdown in each of the first two quarters and shut the Patriots out 13–0.[7]

The two teams met for their first and only playoff match in the AFL divisional game in December 1963. The Patriots won 26–8. In this game, Jack Kemp played quarterback for the Bills and Gino Cappelletti made four field goals and two extra points to help lift the Patriots to victory.[8]

Throughout the remainder of the decade, the teams would complete a 12–9 record in favor of the Patriots. The Bills won the AFL championship game in 1964 and 1965, and won the division in 1966. The Patriots lost to the San Diego Chargers in their only AFLchampionship appearance in 1963.


Both teams were placed into the AFC East after the AFL–NFL merger. During this time period, the Bills went 12–8 against the Patriots. The Bills sustained a winning streak of 9 games from 1971 to 1975.[1] The two teams played a pair of highly competitive games in the 1974 season. The Bills withstood a late Patriots rally at Rich Stadium to win, 30–28. Two weeks later, the Bills edged the Patriots, 29–28, when a last-second field goal attempt by the Patriots was blocked.

O.J. Simpson had one of the most dramatic games of his career on November 23, 1975 against the Patriots. Simpson ran in two touchdowns and caught two touchdown passes from Joe Ferguson as the Bills won, 45–31. Patriots rookie Steve Grogan threw for 365 yards and two touchdowns but was intercepted three times.

1976 was Simpson's final year in Buffalo; on October 24 Simpson rushed for 110 yards and two touchdowns in a 26–22 Patriots win. Two weeks later on November 7 Simpson was held to just eight rushing yards and was ejected following a scuffle at midfield; Patriots rookie Mike Haynes ran back a second quarter punt 89 yards for a touchdown, the first such touchdown in Patriots history. The Patriots won the game, 20–10, their first season sweep of the Bills since 1968.


The 1980s was a dominant decade for the Patriots, as they won the decade series 13–6. The Patriots also completed their own 11-game winning streak over the Bills from January 1983 to September 1988. The Bills began to rebuild their team in the late 1980s with the additions of Jim Kelly at quarterback, Thurman Thomas as running back, Andre Reed as a receiver, Bruce Smith on defense, and Marv Levy as coach. The Bills bested the Patriots to win the AFC East division four years in a row from 1988–92. During the final stretch of the 1980s, the Bills took three out of four meetings with the Patriots.[1]


In the 1990 season, the Bills reached the Super Bowl for the first time, playing against the New York Giants in Super Bowl XXV. Although obviously not a game in the rivalry, the 1990 Giants were coached by Bill Parcells (who had been linebackers coach with the Patriots in 1980) and defensive coordinator Bill Belichick; both would become head coach of the Patriots. The Giants won 20–19.

The Bills continued to dominate the Patriots in the early 1990s, winning eight of the first nine games, including five straight. New England, however, made the rivalry more competitive with the addition of Drew Bledsoe as quarterback and the hiring of Parcells as head coach. The Bills also saw many of their Super Bowl players leave during this time period. By the end of the 1990s, the Bills led the decade with 12 wins to the Patriots' 8 wins.[1] Throughout the decade, the two teams combined to win the AFC East six times, with the Patriots reaching the Super Bowl in 1996 and the Bills reaching the Super Bowl in 1990, 1991, 1992, and 1993.

The decade saw several memorable games between the two. On September 11, 1994, Buffalo led 28–14 at the half and 35–21 at the start of the fourth quarter after Mike Lodish grabbed a Patriots fumble at the New England goalline. The Patriots scored two touchdowns to tie, the game but Buffalo won 38–35 after Steve Christie booted a 32-yard field goal as time expired.

Late that season the Bills hosted the Patriots. Buffalo was 7–7 while the Patriots were 8–6. The Patriots erased a 17–3 gap, scoring 38 unanswered points. Frank Reich, replacing Jim Kelly, was intercepted twice and the Bills fumbled three times; Ricky Reynolds ran back a Buffalo fumble for a touchdown. The 41–17 Patriots win eliminated Buffalo from the playoffs.

1996 was Jim Kelly's last season; his Bills won 17–10 on September 8 on a 63-yard touchdown throw to Quinn Early and then on a last-second goal line stand. On October 27, the Bills had an 18–15 lead at the two-minute warning; Curtis Martin ran in a ten-yard score, then Willie McGinest intercepted Kelly and ran in a 46-yard touchdown, but Kelly then completed a 48-yard touchdown off two Patriots defenders to Andre Reed; the onside kick failed and the Patriots won 28–25.

The 1998 season saw the return of Doug Flutie, who'd been Patriots quarterback in 1988–89; he replaced Rob Johnson as Bills quarterback after Buffalo started 1–3. Flutie led the Bills to win four of his first five starts, including a 13–10 victory over the Patriots at Rich Stadium on November 15, but on November 29 in Flutie's return to Foxboro Stadium the Patriots, despite a broken index finger for Drew Bledsoe, rallied to a controversial last-second touchdown to Ben Coates and a 25–21 Patriots win that was aided by a pass interference penalty against the Bills as time expired.


Bills QB J. P. Losman gets tackled by New England's Ty Warren for the Patriots' game-winning safety in 2006

The 2000s was the most lopsided decade for the rivalry to date. On November 5, 2000 Flutie and the Bills defeated the Patriots and new head coach Bill Belichick at Foxboro Stadium 16–13 in overtime. But after this the Patriots won 18 of the next 19 against the Bills.

This decade also saw several notable personnel changes. Following New England's 2001 championship year, Drew Bledsoe was traded by New England to Buffalo in 2002. Lawyer Milloy was then cut after the 2003 preseason and was immediately signed by Buffalo.[9] Doug Flutie, released by the Bills after 2000, joined the Patriots by way of the San Diego Chargers in 2005.

The Patriots assembled a five-game winning streak over the Bills in the beginning of the decade, which was snapped when Buffalo defeated the Patriots 31–0 in 2003 season. However, the Patriots then defeated the Bills by the same score later in the season. That win began a 15-game winning streak for the Patriots against the Bills stretching through 2010. The Bills did come close to winning on two occasions, but lost both times due to fourth quarter gaffes, surrendering a safety in 2006 to lose 19–17,[10] and fumbling a kickoff return to set up New England's game-winning touchdown in 2009.[11]

On December 28, 2008, the 10–5 Patriots needed a win and help from other teams to win the AFC East, while the 7–8 Bills were wrapping up the ninth straight season without a playoff berth. Played with severe wind gusts that required stadium officials to use ropes to keep the goalposts from swaying, the game was a 13–0 Patriots win as Matt Cassel, subbing for injured Tom Brady, threw only eight passes. However, the Patriots fell short of the division title.


The game on September 26, 2010 was noteworthy on several levels. The Patriots won 38–30, marking the 400th win in the history of the Patriots franchise (regular-season and playoffs). It was first start of the season for Buffalo's former backup quarterback Ryan Fitzpatrick. Randy Moss caught two touchdowns; they turned out to be his last with the Patriots.

On September 25, 2011, the Bills came back from a 21–0 deficit to defeat the Patriots 34–31 and snap the Patriots' 15-game winning streak.[12] Despite this win, the Patriots won the final meeting of the season, on January 1, 2012, erasing a 21–0 Bills lead to win 49–21[13]

On September 30, 2012 the Patriots erased a 21–7 Bills lead in the third quarter by outscoring them, 45–7 on six straight touchdowns, winning 52–28.[14] On November 11 the Bills stayed toe to toe with the Patriots; down, 37–31, the Bills were driving until Devin McCourty intercepted a Fitzpatrick pass in the endzone.[15]

Following the death of long time Bills owner Ralph Wilson, the Bills were sold to Buffalo Sabres owners Terry Pegula and his wife Kim.[16] In his first game as Bills owner the Bills team hosted the Patriots on October 12, 2014, a 37–22 Patriots win. Tom Brady threw for 361 yards - his 60th 300-yard game - and four touchdowns, including a 43-yard strike to Brian Tyms.[17] In Week 17, the Bills won their first matchup at Gillette Stadium had been built and would be Buffalo's first regulation win in New England in over 20 years. The Patriots having clinched home field advantage throughout the playoffs, played Brady during the first half of the game only. The Patriots played Jimmy Garoppolo in his place in the second half but both failed to find the endzone in the 17–9 Buffalo win.[18]

After the 2014 season, Buffalo hired former New York Jets head coach Rex Ryan.[19] When asked if the Jets would be his focus during the 2015 season, Ryan admitted that the Patriots would still be his number one target.[20]

2016 saw the Patriots hosting the Bills in week 4. The Patriots faced a shortage at quarterback, as Tom Brady was suspended in the aftermath of the Deflategate scandal and primary backup Jimmy Garoppolo was sidelined with an injury. As a result, third-string quarterback Jacoby Brissett made the start for the Patriots.[21] Unable to overcome a strong defensive showing from the Bills and an efficient performance by quarterback Tyrod Taylor, Brissett and the Patriots lost 16–0. It was the first shutout loss at home for New England since 1993.[22] The rematch later in 2016, which the Patriots won 41–25 with Brady returning, was notorious as a spectator tossed a sex toy onto the field in the middle of a play.[23][24]

During a game with playoff implications on December 3, 2017, Patriots tight-end and Buffalo native Rob Gronkowski hit Bills cornerback Tre'Davious White with a flying elbow after White intercepted Tom Brady in garbage-time. Though the game was already decided at that point with the Patriots going on to win 23–3, the play added tension between the teams.[25] During the rematch just three weeks later, Buffalo raced to a 16–13 lead in the third quarter, but ultimately lost 37–16 as Brady led three consecutive touchdown drives. Another controversial moment occurred when Bills receiver Kelvin Benjamin had a touchdown reception overturned during the second quarter.[26]


Buffalo Bills vs. New England Patriots Season-by-Season Results

Connections between the teams[edit]

There have been several players who have played for the Bills and Patriots, including:

  • Doug Flutie[27] – New England Patriots (1987–1989; 2005) and Buffalo Bills (1998–2000)
  • Drew Bledsoe[28] – New England Patriots (1993–2001) and Buffalo Bills (2002–2004)
  • Lawyer Milloy[29] – New England Patriots (1996–2002) and Buffalo Bills (2003–2005)
  • Antowain Smith[30] – Buffalo Bills (1997–2000) and New England Patriots (2001–2003)
  • Fred Smerlas[31] – Buffalo Bills (1979–1989) and New England Patriots (1991–1992)
  • Sam Gash[32] – New England Patriots (1992–1997) and Buffalo Bills (1998–1999; 2003)
  • Larry Centers[33] – Buffalo Bills (2001–2002) and New England Patriots (2003)
  • Charles Johnson[34] – New England Patriots (2001) and Buffalo Bills (2002)
  • Sammy Morris[35] – Buffalo Bills (2000–2003) and New England Patriots (2007–2010)
  • Brandon Spikes[36] – New England Patriots (2010–2013) and Buffalo Bills (2014; 2016)
  • Scott Chandler[37] – Buffalo Bills (2010–2014) and New England Patriots (2015)
  • Chris Hogan[38] – Buffalo Bills (2012–2015) and New England Patriots (2016–2018)
  • Stephon Gilmore[39] – Buffalo Bills (2012–2016) and New England Patriots (2017–)
  • Mike Gillislee[40] – Buffalo Bills (2015–2016) and New England Patriots (2017)
  • Alan Branch[41] – Buffalo Bills (2013) and New England Patriots (2014–2017)

In addition to players, the two teams have shared head coaches. Lou Saban was the first coach in Patriots history but was fired after five games of the 1961 season. He took over the Bills in 1962 and won two American Football League titles (1964–65). After a five-season period in Denver he returned to the Bills for the 1972–76 period.[42]

Hank Bullough coached both teams: He was co-head coach (with Ron Erhardt) for the Patriots at the end of 1978 and coached the Bills for the final twelve games of 1985 and the first nine games of 1986.[43]

Pepper Johnson joined the Bills coaching staff in 2014 after fourteen seasons on the Patriots staff.[44]

Brian Daboll was hired as the Bills' offensive coordinator on January 14, 2018, having previously served as the Patriots' tight-end coach.[45]

In popular culture[edit]

The Bills–Patriots rivalry was satired in the Family Guy episode "3 Acts of God" in which the roles were reversed. In the first part of the episode, Peter Griffin—along with his family and friends—attends a game between the Patriots and Bills at Gillette Stadium, which the Bills win, leading to the Patriots' 10th straight loss. The episode also features Bills players Mario Williams and C. J. Spiller guest starring as themselves.[46]


  1. ^ a b c d "New England Patriots v. Buffalo Bills Results". The Football Database. Retrieved July 31, 2012.
  2. ^ Tom Brady career splits from Pro Football Reference
  3. ^ Kenyon, David (October 30, 2018). "Tom Brady has more wins in Buffalo since 2001 than any Bills QB". Retrieved February 4, 2019.
  4. ^ Jim Kelly career splits from Pro Football Reference
  5. ^ O.J. Simpson career splits from Pro Football Reference
  6. ^ "AFL Legacy Games: Bills vs. Patriots in first ever AFL game". Pro Football Hall of Fame. September 9, 2009. Retrieved July 31, 2012.
  7. ^ "Buffalo Bills at Boston Patriots – September 23rd, 1960". Pro Football Reference. Retrieved July 31, 2012.
  8. ^ "Boston Patriots at Buffalo Bills – Saturday, December 28, 1963". Pro Football Reference. Retrieved August 6, 2012.
  9. ^ "Will Milloy line up against Patriots on Sunday?". September 4, 2003. Retrieved July 31, 2012.
  10. ^ "Bills vs. Patriots - Team Statistics - September 10, 2006 - ESPN". Retrieved August 3, 2017.
  11. ^ Watch Buffalo Bills vs. New England Patriots [09/14/2009]
  12. ^ "Patriots vs. Bills - Game Recap - September 25, 2011 - ESPN". Retrieved August 3, 2017.
  13. ^ "Despite being top seed, Patriots still perplexing". Retrieved August 3, 2017.
  14. ^ "Patriots vs. Bills - Game Recap - September 30, 2012 - ESPN". Retrieved August 3, 2017.
  15. ^ "Bills vs. Patriots - Game Recap - November 11, 2012 - ESPN". Retrieved August 3, 2017.
  16. ^ Bills confirm agreement reached with Pegulas to buy franchise
  17. ^ "Patriots vs. Bills - Game Recap - October 12, 2014 - ESPN". Retrieved August 3, 2017.
  18. ^ "Bills vs. Patriots - Game Recap - December 28, 2014 - ESPN". Retrieved August 3, 2017.
  19. ^ "Rex Ryan: The Bills are going to the playoffs". ProFootballTalk. January 14, 2015. Retrieved August 3, 2017.
  20. ^ "New Bills coach Rex Ryan says Patriots still his top target - The Boston Globe". Archived from the original on March 27, 2019. Retrieved August 3, 2017.
  21. ^ Jacoby Brissett struggles to lead Patriots downfield in loss to Bills[permanent dead link]
  22. ^ "Pre-game scuffle motivates Bills defense to beat Patriots". October 2, 2016. Retrieved August 3, 2017.
  23. ^ Dator, James (October 31, 2016). "Yeah, someone threw a big dildo on the field during Pats-Bills". SB Nation.
  24. ^ Clarkson, Brett (October 31, 2018). "Florida man threw sex toy on field at Bills-Patriots Monday Night Football game, cops say". Sun Sentinel. Retrieved November 4, 2018.
  25. ^ Wawrow, John (December 3, 2017). "Gronk's hit on Tre'Davious White adds tension to Bills, Pats". The Associated Press. ABC News. Retrieved December 4, 2017.
  26. ^ Yang, Nicole (December 24, 2017). "Another touchdown was controversially overturned in favor of the Patriots". Retrieved December 25, 2017.
  27. ^ "Doug Flutie". Retrieved August 3, 2017.
  28. ^ "Drew Bledsoe". Retrieved August 3, 2017.
  29. ^ "Lawyer Milloy". Retrieved August 3, 2017.
  30. ^ "Antowain Smith Stats |". Retrieved August 3, 2017.
  31. ^ "Fred Smerlas: Career Stats at". Retrieved August 3, 2017.
  32. ^ "Sam Gash". Retrieved August 3, 2017.
  33. ^ "Larry Centers Stats |". Retrieved August 3, 2017.
  34. ^ "Charles Johnson". Retrieved August 3, 2017.
  35. ^ "Sammy Morris". Retrieved August 3, 2017.
  36. ^ "Brandon Spikes". Retrieved August 3, 2017.
  37. ^ "Scott Chandler". Retrieved August 3, 2017.
  38. ^ "Chris Hogan". Retrieved August 3, 2017.
  39. ^ "Stephon Gilmore". Retrieved August 3, 2017.
  40. ^ "Mike Gillislee". Retrieved August 3, 2017.
  41. ^ "Alan Branch". Retrieved August 29, 2019.
  42. ^ Lou Saban Archived October 9, 2012, at the Wayback Machine
  43. ^ "Hank Bullough Record, Statistics, and Category Ranks |". Retrieved August 3, 2017.
  44. ^ "Tom Brady: Bills' Brandon Spikes, Pepper Johnson Know Patriots' Style". October 8, 2014. Retrieved August 3, 2017.
  45. ^ Schad, Tom (January 14, 2018). "Buffalo Bills hire Alabama offensive coordinator Brian Daboll". USA Today. Retrieved March 31, 2018.
  46. ^ Miller, Dallas (March 17, 2014). "Bills make primetime appearance on Family Guy". Buffalo Bills. Archived from the original on March 18, 2014. Retrieved June 24, 2018.