Clumsy (Our Lady Peace album)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

A very distressed old man in a blue shirt is seen clutching a trapeze bar in his teeth. The image is made of a collage of pictures against a black background.
Studio album by
ReleasedJanuary 23, 1997
RecordedFebruary – September 1996
StudioArnyard Studios, Toronto, Ontario
ProducerArnold Lanni
Our Lady Peace chronology
Happiness... Is Not a Fish That You Can Catch
Singles from Clumsy
  1. "Superman's Dead"
    Released: December 16, 1996
  2. "Clumsy"
    Released: April 7, 1997
  3. "Automatic Flowers"
    Released: July 14, 1997
  4. "Carnival"
    Released: October 27, 1997
  5. "4am"
    Released: January 12, 1998
Professional ratings
Review scores
AllMusic4/5 stars[1]
AMZ3.5/5 stars[2]
Music Critic4/5 stars[3]
Sputnikmusic4.5/5 stars[4]
Sputnikmusic3.5/5 stars[5]

Clumsy is the second studio album by the Canadian rock band Our Lady Peace, released on January 23, 1997 by Columbia Records. The album is the band's most successful to date, achieving diamond status in Canada (1 million units sold) and strong sales in other countries, including platinum status in the U.S. for another 1 million sales. In 2007, it ranked No. 76 on "The Top 100 Canadian Albums" by Bob Mersereau and No. 33 on The Top 102 New Rock Albums of All Time by 102.1 The Edge (in 2009). The album features five hit singles: "Superman's Dead", "Automatic Flowers", "Clumsy", "4am" and "Carnival". Each single has its own music video, with the exception of "Carnival".


While on tour in support of Naveed the band attempted to begin writing for their next album. Like most bands, the challenges of writing a successful follow-up album was found to be difficult as each member now approached the writing process from a different set of experiences, personal goals, and influences from their time spent touring. Collaborations between band members and the co-writing producer broke down and writing sessions at the producer's studio resulted in nothing of use. The decision was made by Raine Maida that the way to resolve the situation was to change the line-up. It was either Mike Turner or Chris Eacrett. The concern then turned to what challenges would be faced with the task of replacing either. With Turner threatening legal recourse and Maida's school friend Duncan Coutts a bass player in his own band, the choice was simple. Immediately following the band's opening stint with Van Halen Coutts was asked to join the band to be its new permanent bass player. "I don't want to call our old bass player Chris a weak link...I think he's a talented musician, just different from us." claimed Maida at the time of the announcement. Turner would be later fired from the group in the first week of writing with producer Bob Rock (Aerosmith, Metallica, Bon Jovi, Motley Crue) on a subsequent album.


As touring continued, the band began writing again with Duncan. One of the first songs they wrote was the eventual concert favorite "Trapeze", which they played live along with two other newly written songs "Home" and "Disgusted".[6] "Disgusted" would evolve into "Spider Gun" and eventually became the track "Big Dumb Rocket". In December 1995 the band began intensive writing and demoing sessions in a rented rehearsal space. Despite coming up with several new ideas, the band found that writing while on tour was very difficult because they couldn't give the songs their undivided attention and most of their early ideas were scrapped because the band wasn't satisfied with them.[7] "Trapeze" would make it to recording but the track was eventually cut and has yet to be released.[8]

Pre-production for the album was set to begin in January 1996. Producer Arnold Lanni noticed the band's discontent with the songs they were writing. "I went down to see them and knew it wasn't happening", he recalled. "All their friends and family were calling them up. You sell that many records, you're on everybody's A-list, everybody blows sunshine up your butt and sometimes you believe the hype. We had to pull the plug on that scenario."[9] At Lanni's suggestion, the band and him traveled to Duncan's rural lakeside cottage near Muskoka, Ontario, in order to concentrate on writing and recording demos for the album without distractions from family, friends or the media.[7] While there, the band lived together in the cottage surrounded by instruments. A tape recorder was left on in the house all day to pick up any ideas being played. Lanni and the band members would usually play ice hockey in the afternoon and collaborate on songs in the evening and into the night. By the end of their stay, around 20 songs had been written.[10] When they returned to the Toronto studio in February, according to Mike Turner, "When we came back to record, it just came together".[11]

Recording and production[edit]

Recording sessions for the yet untitled album began on February 8, 1996. The band was asked to record the Beatles song "Tomorrow Never Knows" for the soundtrack to the upcoming movie The Craft after several bands they had played with on tour knew them to play it well live. The song was recorded on the very first day of recording with Arnold Lanni and was mixed by Ralph Sall for the soundtrack. They then proceeded to pare down the twenty tracks they had written to the twelve they wanted to record. "The Story of 100 Aisles", originally called "Anacin", was the first song recorded and has a sound closer to Naveed than any other song on the album. "We just wanted to go in and give all these songs ideas their own life and play with them and rearrange them and all that until we're completely happy with it." said Duncan Coutts, "If they sound just like Naveed or if they don't, it wasn't a huge concern. We just wanted to make each song the best it could be."[12]

The album was recorded in two parts. Five or six tracks were recorded and finished by April 1996 so the band could review them. These included the base tracks for "Clumsy", "Hello Oskar", "Carnival", "Shaking", "Let You Down" and "Sleeping In", which didn't make the album.[13] The band's feedback directed the next set of songs recorded around June, which included "Superman's Dead" and a re-recording of "Hello Oscar".[14] Raine Maida said in an interview, "We took a lot of time experimenting. The album was really done in three months. We took another two months to really go back over stuff and re-record. It's neat to look back and know the extra time we took was important to the record."[15] Around this time (April), the working title of the album was Propeller, as Raine explained, "as in, that which causes forward movement." This was probably as a testament to the band's evolution since their debut album.[16] Another working title was Trapeze, named after the song that didn't make the album. The cover art proves that this title came close to being chosen. The name was changed to Clumsy in early September. Recording wrapped up by the end of that month.[17] The album was mastered at Gateway Studios in Portland, Maine by Bob Ludwig.[18]

Style and themes[edit]

Raine stated that there was a kind of "Carnival atmosphere" to the whole album and that many of the lyrics he wrote were set at the circus or a carnival.[14] Clumsy's songs feature the striking vocals of lead vocalist Raine Maida, who utilizes an often jarring falsetto technique: Maida jumps from lower octaves in his vocal range to higher ones. Raine's vocals provide most of the melody of the songs, with guitars quieted down in this album compared to Naveed, their previous album. This aspect of singing has become the staple sound of the band, continuing with this fashion in their next studio album Happiness...Is Not a Fish That You Can Catch, and since lost on their 2005 album Healthy in Paranoid Times.. In a January 1997 interview, the band stated that then new bassist Duncan Coutts, who also plays cello, keyboards and sings background vocals, influenced the sound on Clumsy even though he doesn't have any songwriting credits.[19] He broadened the band's palette of sounds. Given those new parameters, the band couldn't help but change their sound.[8]


In early 1996, Our Lady Peace's American label, Relativity Records, in a decision to switch to an urban format, eliminated ten label positions in their Rock category, including OLP.[20] They moved to another Sony-owned label, Columbia Records for the release of Clumsy's first single in Canada, "Superman's Dead". Columbia would handle all of the band's releases in both Canada and the United States.

Commercial performance[edit]

Clumsy debuted at #1 in Canada, selling 26,000 copies during its first week.[21] It would go on to become Our Lady Peace's best-selling album. On February 28, 2001, the album was certified Diamond in Canada.[22] On July 12, 2004, Clumsy was certified Platinum in the United States.[23]


Our Lady Peace toured in support of Clumsy from a month before the album's release in early 1997 and into 1998. The first leg of the tour, focusing on Canadian colleges, kicked off at Loyalist College in Belleville, Ontario on January 13, 1997 where eight of the album's eleven tracks were premiered including "Superman's Dead", "4 AM" and others. This leg of the tour continued until March 1997, ending with a private music industry show at the Elbow Room in New York City.

The tour's second leg began on May 2, with the band playing two shows in Michigan before going off to Europe to promote the album's recent release there. The band returned and toured across the United States, only dipping into Canada to play at the very first Summersault festival. The North American tour continued until the end of September 1997 when Our Lady Peace joined Everclear as an opening act with whom they would tour until the end of 1997.[24]

In January 1998, the band embarked on a 22-date headlining tour across Canada which included several shows opening for The Rolling Stones. On February 26, Our Lady Peace began their first headlining tour in the United States with Headswim and Black Lab opening. Following this they returned to Europe again for a 14-show tour across Belgium, the Netherlands, France and Germany. Further touring in the U.S. with Third Eye Blind and Eve 6 lasted into September 1998. The year of touring was concluded with the second Summersault festival being held. Our Lady Peace would spend the rest of the year working on their third studio album, Happiness... Is Not a Fish That You Can Catch.

Re-creation tour[edit]

In December 2009, the band announced that they would be "recreating"[25] both Clumsy and their 2000 record Spiritual Machines by performing them live in their entireties[25][26][27] throughout a new tour that began in March 2010; only nine months before the 10-year anniversary of the release of Spiritual Machines.[25]

Track listing[edit]

All tracks written by Mike Turner, Raine Maida, Jeremy Taggart and Arnold Lanni. Words by Raine Maida.

1."Superman's Dead"4:16
2."Automatic Flowers"4:05
4."Big Dumb Rocket"4:23
8."Hello Oskar"3:03
9."Let You Down"3:53
10."The Story of 100 Aisles"3:45
11."Car Crash"5:07
Total length:45:43
European bonus tracks
14."Automatic Flowers"3:54
  • Recorded live at CBC Studios, Vancouver, April 25, 1997


As listed in liner notes.[18]

Non-album tracks[edit]

Library sampler[edit]

Released in 1998, this promo contained various versions of songs from Clumsy and Naveed.

  1. "4am" (radio edit) – 3:30
  2. "4am" (album version) – 4:15
  3. "Clumsy" (power acoustic version) – 4:00
  4. "Clumsy" (album version) – 4:28
  5. "Superman's Dead" (radio edit) – 3:44
  6. "Superman's Dead" (live from Irving Plaza, NYC) – 4:53
  7. "Starseed" (Armageddon remix) – 4:20
  8. "Starseed" – 4:04
  9. "Naveed" (edit) – 4:39

Release history[edit]

Region Date Label Catalog
Canada January 23, 1997 Columbia CK 80242
United States April 8, 1997 CK 67940
France April 14, 1997[28]
Europe September 29, 1997 Epic EPC 487408 2


  1. ^ Wilson, MacKenzie. "Review: Clumsy". AllMusic. Retrieved March 6, 2010.
  2. ^ "AMZ review". Archived from the original on January 16, 2006. Retrieved March 7, 2010.
  3. ^ Aicher, Bill. "Our Lady Peace: Clumsy". Music Retrieved March 6, 2010.
  4. ^ Mike Stagno (Sputnikmusic) review
  5. ^ Dave de Sylvia (Sputnikmusic) review
  6. ^ LePage, Mark. "Our Lady Peace tests new work on grateful fans :[FINAL Edition]. " The Montreal Gazette March 30, 1996, ProQuest Newsstand, ProQuest. Web. Retrieved September 28, 2010.
  7. ^ a b Ohler, Shawn "Our Lady Peace on track with new album" – The Edmonton Journal January 23, 1997. Retrieved December 7, 2009
  8. ^ a b Hudecek, Lukas "Falling with Talent Archived June 11, 2011, at the Wayback Machine" – UWO Gazette January 22, 1997. Retrieved December 7, 2009
  9. ^ Anon. "Clumsy Learning Curve" – Words and Music Jul. – Aug. 1997. Retrieved December 7, 2009
  10. ^ "Transparent Humans Mailing List – Digest #17" January 29, 1996
  11. ^ Wilton, Lisa "Jinx? What jinx?" – August 26, 1997. Retrieved August 1, 2009
  12. ^ Ross, Mike "A Peace of the Action: Duncan Coutts signs on with one of Canada's top rock bands" – January 21, 1997. Retrieved December 7, 2009
  13. ^ "Transparent Humans Mailing List – Digest #37" May 29, 1996
  14. ^ a b Sakamoto, John "Our Lady ready to fly with new release" – May 15, 1996. Retrieved August 1, 2009
  15. ^ "Peace time" – January 23, 1997 article at Canoe Jam! Retrieved August 1, 2009
  16. ^ "Transparent Humans Mailing List – Digest #32" April 8, 1996
  17. ^ "Transparent Humans Mailing List – Digest #47" September 3, 1996
  18. ^ a b Clumsy (CD). Our Lady Peace. Columbia Records. 1997. 67940.CS1 maint: others (link)
  19. ^ Stevenson, Jane "Our Lady Peace building on fanbase" – Toronto Sun January 21, 1997. Retrieved August 1, 2009
  20. ^ Newman, Melinda "Relativity Answers Call of Urban Jungle"Columbia Offers More 'Sweet Relief'" Billboard February 3, 1996. Retrieved March 29, 2010
  21. ^ "TWO IN A ROW: OUR LADY PEACE DEBUT AT #1 IN CANADA!". Chart Attack. Retrieved January 21, 2019.
  22. ^ "Gold/Platinum". Music Canada. Retrieved January 21, 2019.
  23. ^ "GOLD & PLATINUM". RIAA. Retrieved January 21, 2019.
  24. ^ LeBlanc, Larry. "Our Lady Peace a hit on Columbia. " Billboard (magazine) February 7, 1998: JuniorQuest Magazines, ProQuest. Web. Retrieved September 28, 2010.
  25. ^ a b c An Evening with Our Lady Peace — Retrieved December 7, 2009.
  26. ^ Harper, Kate "Our Lady Peace Playing Clumsy, Spiritual Machines On Tour Archived December 12, 2009, at the Wayback Machine" – Chartattack December 7, 2009. Retrieved December 13, 2009
  27. ^ Raine Retrieved December 7, 2009.
  28. ^ "Les Albums – Our Lady Peace". (French). Retrieved January 31, 2010.

External links[edit]