Paper money of the Qing dynasty
The paper money of the Qing dynasty (Traditional Chinese: 清朝鈔票) was periodically used alongside a bimetallic coinage system of copper-alloy cash coins and silver sycees; paper money was used during different periods of Chinese history under the Manchu-led Qing as the Qing had learned from the previous experiences of the Song, Jurchen Jin, Mongol Yuan, and Ming dynasties with paper money where uncontrolled printing lead to hyperinflation. During the youngest days of the Qing dynasty paper money was used but this was quickly abolished as the government sought not to repeat history for a fourth time, however under the reign of the Xianfeng Emperor due to several large wars and rebellions (most notably the Taiping Rebellion) the Qing government was forced to issue paper money again.
The reason why the government was forced to reform the imperial monetary system with a very complex system during the Taiping Rebellion was because the rebels had blocked the access of mint metals from the southwest of China, but more money was still needed to fight the ongoing insurgency. The advisors of the Xianfeng Emperor not only introduced copper-alloy cash coins with higher denominations than one, as well as introducing new cash coins made of metals other than brass, but also revived paper money in the shape of the Xianfeng Baochao (咸豐寶鈔). Quite important for the war effort is the fact that the imperial Qing government earned some revenue by issuing these new types of currencies.
During the latter half of the 19th century various foreign banking corporations and credit institutes started doing business in China. The paper notes issued by these companies started circulating in China leading to many local companies imitating their designs and even outsourcing the production of paper money. The strong influence of these foreign banks had a modernising effect on both the economy and the currency of the Qing dynasty, leading to the imperial government issuing their own versions of modern paper money. The denominations on the paper money were as chaotic as that of the coinage types and the different exchange rates used regionally were also applied locally while banknotes denominated in copper-alloy currency had a different value than banknotes denominated in silver currency. Concurrently banknotes issued by different branches or different banks were also discounted with paper bills issued by more reliable banks being both valued more and in higher demand than those issued by institutions with a less favourable reputation.
In the early 20th century the government of the Qing dynasty attempted to decimalise the currency among many other economic reforms and established a national bank to oversee the production of paper money, however the chaotic monetary situation continued to plague interregional trade and would later be inherited by the Republic of China.
- 1 History
- 2 List of banknotes denominated in copper-alloy cash coins issued during the Xianfeng era
- 3 List of banknotes denominated in silver taels issued during the Xianfeng era
- 4 Banknotes produced by Belgian banks
- 5 Banknotes produced by British banks
- 6 Banknotes produced by French banks
- 7 Banknotes produced by Japanese banks
- 8 Banknotes produced by Russian banks
- 9 Deutsch-Asiatische Bank
- 10 International Banking Corporation
- 11 Netherlands Trading Society
- 12 Denominations used on paper money during the late Qing period
- 13 Denominations on banknotes of foreign banks in Qing China
- 14 Banknotes as a percentage of the Chinese money stock during the late Qing dynasty
- 15 Gallery
- 16 See also
- 17 Notes
- 18 References
- 19 Sources
Hubu Guanpiao and other early Qing paper money
During the transition from Ming to Qing the Manchu government issued banknotes known as Hubu Guanpiao (戶部官票) or Shunzhi Guanpiao (順治官票) which were first issued in the year 1651 on initiative of the Minister of Revenue, Wei Xiangshu (魏象樞) during the war with the remnants of the Ming dynasty to cover the more immediate expenses of the Manchus; as the finances of the Qing during this period were in dire distress, these banknotes were declared void only a decade after their issued. Peng Xinwei suggests that the Manchus started issuing banknotes in response to the treasury of the Qing dynasty experiencing funding shortfalls which were occasioned by the a campaign to occupy the island of Zhoushan (near modern Shanghai). An annual amount of 128,000 guàn (貫) were issued, with a total sum of 1.28 million guàn being produced before they were abolished. The denominations of the Hubu Guanpiao followed the pattern of the Ming dynasty period paper notes, but as historiographical sources about the early Qing era paper money are scarce, not much can be known about them.
After the Hubu Guanpiao it was only rarely suggested by court officials to reintroduce paper money to the Qing Empire. Among these were Cai Zhiding (蔡之定) in 1814 and Wang Yide (王懿德) in his treatise on money known as Qianbi Chuyan (錢幣芻言). Peng Xinwei suggested that the Manchu rulers of the Qing were very much atavistic towards the inflationary pressure that the earlier Jurchen Empire experienced after they had abused their ability to print Jiaochao banknotes. Modern scholars argue that the banknotes issued during the Shunzhi period, while only brief, likely entrenched the reluctance of the Qing dynasty to issue banknotes because this issue also proved inflationary confirming their fears.
During this era, privately produced paper notes and promissory notes known as Sipiao (私票) were used in the Chinese market that were mostly issued by private banks (錢莊) and other merchants. These banknotes were known as like Huipiao (會票, "corporate notes"), Yinpiao (銀票, "silver notes"), or Qianpiao (錢票, "cash notes"). As is usual for China, the names designating privately produced banknotes varied greatly across the country, with names being used such as Pingtie (憑帖), Duitie (兌帖), Shangtie (上帖), Hupingtie (壺瓶帖), or Qitie (期帖). The denominations used on them varied greatly with some reaching as high as 5 diào (吊, "string of cash coins"). It has been suggested by Taiwanese economic historian Lin Man-houng that Chinese money shops did not start the production of their own private banknotes until the end of the Qianlong period. These shops were very likely to have been more developed in Northern China, where these money shops produced banknotes which were mostly denominated in cash coins, while banknotes from Southern China tended to be denominated in taels of silver. It is also possible that private-order banknotes could have emerged earlier in the 18th century and that their presence would become very common by the 1820s.
By the middle of the 1800s various Western credit institutes and foreign banking corporations were operating in the Qing dynasty. During the late 1840s they began producing bills of exchange, promissory notes, or other forms of paper money for the Chinese market, which the Chinese referred to as Fanpiao (番票). This introduced modern credit instruments to the traditional Chinese business world and greatly bolstered the reformist monetary discourse in China and would later be emulated by homegrown Chinese modern banks. This affected both the private market and the imperial Chinese bureaucracy.
Xianfeng era paper money
During most of the Manchu Qing dynasty, the monetary system largely relied mostly on copper-alloy cash coins (銅錢) denominated in wén (文) for small transactions and the general retail market and silver sycees (銀兩 or 銀錠) denominated in taels (兩) for larger transactions and the wholesale market. The general exchange rates between these two currencies fluctuated based both on time and on the location they were traded in, however the official exchange course was set by the imperial government as 1000 wén of copper-alloy cash coins for 1 tael of silver. Prior to the year 1800, the exchange rates were actually closer to 700 or 800 wén for 1 tael, but by the 19th century this has increased to 1200 wén. By the second half of the 19th century the imperial government of the Qing decided to experiment with cash coins that had a denomination higher than 1 wén which were known as Daqian, (大錢, "large money") because of copper shortages, but as the shortages ran higher the government decided to reintroduce paper money.
Under the reign of the Xianfeng Emperor the Da-Qing Baochao (大清寶鈔) was introduced. These were based on the earlier Da-Ming Baochao from the Ming dynasty in style and layout and denominated in Zhiqian (制錢, "Standard cash coins") which were the high quality cash coins issued by the two central government mints in Beijing. For this reason they were popularly nicknamed Qianpiao (錢票, "cash notes"). These banknotes were initially issued in the denominations 250 wén, 500 wén, 1,000 wén, 1,500 wén, and 2,000 wén but as the Chinese economy was suffering from inflation denominations of 5,000 wén, 10,000 wén, 50,000 wén and 100,000 wén were introduced. The Da-Qing Baochao notes were imprinted with a statement that they were convertible into copper cash coins, however the statement also included the line that these banknotes could not be used for tax payment to the government. In reality the Da-Qing Baochao were not redeemable at all. Imperial China saw itself as being at the center of the universe and that all territory "Under the Heavens" (天下) and "Regions Within the Four Seas" (四海) were included within their domains, and for this reason the copper-alloy cash notes of this era bear the four characters "Tian xia tong xing" (天下通行) in their right border design, which translated into English means "to circulate under the heavens".
The Da-Qing Baochao banknotes were supposed to enjoy circulation in all territories of the Qing dynasty. In order to facilitate this widespread adoption of the new paper currency, the Da-Qing Baochao banknotes were issued to the general public through semi-official banks known as the Yu banks,[a] Ch'ien banks, and T'ien bank groups; these semi-official banks served as the fiscal agents of the Ministry of Revenue. In reality however, these banking groups were both independent from the Chinese government and from each other and weren’t under any form of imperial government supervision. There were five "Yu Banks" which were already existing Chinese private banks, while the Ch'ien and T'ien banks were large cash shops which received a government license to distribute the new paper currency. The T'ien shops also fulfilled the purpose of being publicly funded pawnshops; they dealt in both pawned items and deposits. It is important to note that none of these institutions would survive the inflation, drowning in an ever increasing sea of Da-Qing Baochao cash notes. By the year Xianfeng 11 (1861) these institutions had all closed as they went bankrupt. The fall of the T'ien shops was quickened by Chinese peasants who, with the inflation affecting the paper money running rampant, opted to speedily redeem their pawned items with the depreciated Da-Qing Baochao. This run on the T'ien shops practically doomed the Chinese pawnshop business overnight.
During this era another type of banknote was also introduced known as the Yinpiao (銀票, "silver notes") or Yinchao (銀鈔, "silver notes") which were issued by the Ministry of Revenue and were commonly known as Hubu Guanpiao (戶部官票) for this fact. These silver notes were issued in denominations of values 1 tael, 3 taels, 5 taels, 10 taels, and 50 taels. These banknotes had a guideline written in both Manchu and Mandarin Chinese declaring that they had to be discounted by 2% when they exchanged into Beijing market silver and when counted against the Kuping tael, the Yinpiao notes were discounted at 6 per cent. The conversion rate between copper-alloy cash notes (錢鈔) and silver tael notes (官票) was 2 cash notes to 1 silver note, these banknotes exchangeable into copper cash coins and silver, but only in certain institutions in Beijing under the Ministry of Revenue. The term Chaopiao (鈔票) was first used exclusively for paper notes issued by the imperial government, but later on was also used to refer to privately produced paper notes issued by private market banks and merchant companies.
These banknotes were all introduced in the year 1854 and during the first few months after they were minted they started being distributed in the form of salary for both government officials and the military, however the imperial government itself did not accept them as a method of payment including for taxation, likewise many provincial governments also refused to accept the new paper currency. Later on these banknotes were slowly gaining acceptance throughout the Qing Empire. Consequentially due to their limited acceptability these paper notes were severely discounted in the private market sector, if accepted at all. In the year 1855 a cash note of 1000 wén or a silver note of 1 tael were just accepted for 450 Beijing cash (Jingqian, 京錢) or 200-300 standard cash coins by the private market. The market value of paper currency would consistently decrease as the imperial government kept printing both more of it and higher denominations, and by the year 1861 the government mandated paper money had overstayed their usefulness and consequently was completely abolished. During this year Yinchao had already disappeared from general circulation, and a 1,000 wén cash note had a market value of as little as 26 wén, or 52 wén at the most.
During the period when the Da-Qing Baochao and Hubu Guanpiao series of banknotes were introduced, nine government banks in Beijing (of which four were newly established institutions) started issuing another type of cash note known as the Guanhao Qianpiao (官號錢票). These cash notes were backed by reserves kept in Daqian rather than standard cash coins. The Guanhao Qianpiao were modeled after privately produced banknotes known as the Sihao Qianpiao (私號錢票). These private cash notes would also continue to circulate alongside the new currencies. Both the Guanhao Qianpiao and Sihao Qianpiao were based on the Jingqian accounting unit of cash coins as was used in Beijing. This meant that, for example, if one were to exchange 15,000 wén worth of Guanhao Qianpiao or Sihao Qianpiao cash notes in the year 1861, that person would only receive 7500 wén worth of physical coins (or 750 cash coins of 10 wén to be more precise). This practice was asymmetrical as government documents noted a string of cash coins as 1000 wén while paying out only 500 wén for these cash notes. Both the Da-Qing Baochao cash notes and Hubu Guanpiao tael notes continued to be accepted in the practice of office selling and would continue to circulate in the provinces of China proper as non-interest bearing debentures until the years 1867–1868.
During the early Tongzhi era (同治, 1862–1874), the provincial governments of Henan and Sichuan completely stopped accepting paper money for tax payments and again began requiring tax payments exclusively in silver, yet the provincial government of Zhili continued to accept the paper notes for tax payments, at least in a certain proportion to silver, which was preferred. The Xianfeng era paper currency was ultimately given up in the year 1868.
Foreign banks and the currency reforms of the late 19th and early 20th centuries
During the final decades of the 19th century, private Chinese banks and merchant companies used two types of paper money for their daily exchanges; one type was denominated in Chinese money and the other type was denominated in foreign currencies. Various foreign banks in China, which were locally known as yanghang (洋行) or waishang yinhang (外商銀行), issued paper money for local circulation. These foreign financial institutions both challenged the Chinese banking system and set an example for them to improve themselves. Foreign banks were crucial in laying the foundation for the rise of modern Chinese banks and the popularisation of banknotes in the Qing dynasty in the beginning 20th century. These foreign banks included Mackellar (麥加利), the Hong Kong and Shanghai Banking Corporation (匯豐銀行), the Deutsch-Asiatische Bank (德華銀行), and the City Bank of New York (花旗) produced notes denominated in silver taels (銀兩) and Chinese silver dollars (銀元). The banknotes of Mackellar, the HSBC, and the Deutsch-Asiatische Bank were denominated in 1 tael, 5 taels, 10 taels, 50 taels, and 100 taels, while the banknotes issued by the City Bank of New York were denominated in 1 yuan, 3 yuan, 10 yuan, 50 yuan, and 100 yuan. These banknotes were commonly used in the region around the Yangtze River. Meanwhile in Manchuria the Russo-Chinese Bank (華俄道勝銀行) issued Russian ruble notes (盧布票) and the Japanese banks operating in the region issued military notes (軍用票). In Southern China the Yokohama Specie Bank (横浜正金銀行) issued gold notes (金票) and Hong Kong notes (香幣) for the local market. Foreign banks established branches throughout imperial China in order to facilitate trade with the home country of those operating these companies. These credit institutions were not permitted to operate wherever they wished to set up an office and had no right to do business outside their assigned jurisdictions as their operations were limited to the "treaty ports" which the Chinese government had set aside under the terms of the indemnity laws enforced upon the Qing dynasty after losing two opium wars. Operating entirely within the foreign-held enclaves of China, these banks were not subject to Chinese law, rather they were operating under the banking laws of their respective mother countries. Some foreign banks also maintained several branches in multiple treaty ports, which permitted a bank in one locality to discount its own banknotes from another branch. Despite the restrictions placed upon foreign banks their operations, with few exceptions, were so successful that the Chinese people preferred them over "indigenous" Chinese banks. Because their operations were so reliably managed, the banknotes issued by the foreign banks were in great demand and consequently circulated throughout all of Qing territory.
The main financial institutions serving as intermediaries between the Europeans and the Chinese for financial purposes were the Qianzhuang (錢莊, known in English as "money shops" or "native banks"), the Qianzhuang tended to be small proprietorships which had unlimited liability. These financial institutions were often sparsely aligned along family and linguistic ties and they were rarely patronised by the local government authorities. Larger Qianzhuang would issue company scrip against individual deposits which were known as Zhuangpiao (莊票, "shop coupon"). This scrip was also accepted by proximate shops, but to cash these out would take around 10–15 days after it was given to the shop. This was because couriers would have to liaise with the issuing shop in order to rule out fraudulent Zhuangpiao notes. During the 1860s the Qianzhuang of Shanghai started looking to the foreign banking companies as a source of capital, and by the year 1888, sixty-two of the largest Qianzhuang had engaged in borrowing millions of taels in silver in loans from foreign banks on a yearly basis. The Qianzhuang would mobilise their domestic resources to an order of magnitude that would exceed the paid-up capital that they initially received several times over; this happened mostly through issuing banknotes and deposit receipts. British banks operating in China would often accept Zhuangpiao as a security for the loans they gave out to Qianzhuang. This makes it plausible that chop loans originated because of the wildely used prevalence of Zhuangpiao in China that British banks could simply not just to reject them when they were being offered to them by foreign merchants in China. During this era foreign banking companies tended to have an account at least one Qianzhuang, since only the guilds operated by them could clear the large number Zhuangpiao forms that were circulating in the city of Shanghai, this happened through a rather elaborate daily mechanism which was dubbed Huihua (非匯, "draft exchange").
The main business foreign banks conducted themselves in was the handling of bills of exchange for which foreign banks enjoyed a practical monopoly in the lucrative foreign exchange business. The foreign banks were in such a dominant position that they dominated exchange rates between China and the outside world. As China was made up of many different types of currency in its different geographical areas, there existed a great opportunity for profit which foreigners benefited from. The currency situation in China made this profitability possible for the simple reason that in China hard money was always viewed as a commodity which only coincidentally served as a medium of exchange. This meant that a foreign bank's buying and selling rates on currency in circulation differed, generally returning a net profit to the bank on each and every transaction dealing with money exchange. Additional sources of income for foreign banks operating in China were derived from floating loans for the cash-starved government of the Qing dynasty and by transmitting remittances to and from China.
The monetary units "yuan" (元 and 圓) were first seen during the late 18th century and were used on foreign issued banknotes. In the year 1895 the first Chinese banknotes denominated in "yuan" (圓) were issued, by the government-owned State Railway Company of Beiyang (北洋鐵軌官路局). These banknotes were printed in the city of London in the United Kingdom and generally seen seen as the first modern paper bills of China, as they are designed in a horizontal mode and in much smaller format than the traditional Chinese paper notes, and inscribed in Mandarin Chinese and English ("Imperial Chinese Railways"). In 1895 the Central Paper Money Office in Tainan (臺南官銀錢票總局) in Taiwan issued banknotes denominated in the currency unit dayuan (大圓, "big yuan"), and had the denominations 1 dayuan, 5 dayuan, and 10 dayuan, however these banknotes followed the traditional design of Chinese paper notes.
The Imperial Bank of China (中華帝國銀行) was founded in the year 1897 based on a suggestion made by Sheng Xuanhuai (盛宣懷, 1844–1916). In 1898 it began issuing the first Chinese commercial cheques (兌換券) which were denominated in taels or in yuan. The IBC is also notable for being the first Chinese bank to order its banknotes from foreign printing bureaus. In 1913 (after the fall of the Qing dynasty) the Imperial Bank of China was renamed the Commercial Bank of China (中國商業銀行). Various provincial authorities also started issuing local paper money during this era. In the province of Hubei, the local Money Office (官錢局) started producing banknotes of 1000 wén which used the traditional Chinese banknote designs, later in 1899 the Zhang Zhidong (張之洞), Viceroy of Huguang ordered the local money office to also start making modern-style banknotes. The production of these was outsourced to the Empire of Japan using high-quality methods, however the design of these banknotes were still vertical as opposed to the horizontal banknotes used elsewhere. In the province of Guangdong, a series of modern-style banknotes was introduced in year 1904 which were denominated in 1 yuan, 5 yuan, and 10 yuan. These banknotes were printed by the Japanese Ministry of the Treasury (日本大藏省), but unlike the notes printed for Hubei had a Western-style vertical design.
The principal function of a foreign bank was to promote and finance foreign trade. For this reason foreign banks in Qing China could only finance projects within the treaty ports and were not allowed to participate in those beyond without sanction of the imperial Chinese government. In this way foreign banks did not compete with the interests of the local Chinese commercial banks. Typically, a foreign bank would return an annual profit of from 15% to 20% to its shareholders. The funds held on deposit by foreign banks were always large, and compared to the funds of Chinese commercial banks were extremely secure, as the bulk of them represented Chinese customs and salt revenues held as collateral against foreign loans. Because of this security, the banknotes issued by foreign banks were in great demand by the Chinese causing them to circulate freely throughout the Chinese empire, in contrast to the limitations placed upon the banks' operations which were only allowed inside of the treaty ports.
During the late Qing dynasty period the old paper notes remained in common usage; these included the traditional privately produced paper notes which were printed on just one side of the bill issued by merchants banks known as Qianzhuang (錢莊), Yinhao (銀號), and Shangpiao (商票) and pawn shops known as Diandang (典當), as well as the old-style banknotes issued by provincial government institutions, to the modern banknotes which were introduced by a dozen or so of foreign banks operating in China and modern Chinese banks which were created in very large numbers in the later years of the 19th century. Furthermore there were also banknotes which were brought into the Chinese financial markets by imperial government-owned firms like railway companies, and foreign bills coming to China through the trade ports like Shanghai. The large spectrum of these types of paper money reflected the structure of the general Chinese credit market in the late Qing period. The traditional Chinese credit institutes were local Qianzhuang banks, Yinhao banks, Piaohao banks, and pawnshops, of which a considerably number was always to be found in each city across the Chinese Empire. Many provincial governments founded their own local provincial, state-owned banks which were known as Guanqianju (官錢局) or Guanyinhao (官銀號), in some provinces even several modern credit institutes were to be found, like the Yuning Bank (裕寧官銀錢局) and the Yusu Bank (裕蘇官銀錢局) in the province of Jiangsu. Quite a few of these provincial credit companies even opened branches in other provinces due to their success.
After it became clear to the Qing government that their finances weren’t going to remain self-sufficient in light of the two Opium Wars, the First Sino-Japanese War, and the Boxer Rebellion, the imperial Chinese court decided that it would have to raise capital through the foreign banking corporations operating in China. The Chinese defeats during these wars were perceived as being "unexpected" by the Qing government and threw it into a state of turmoil, the Qing was plunged deeply into debt to pay for war indemnities making the need for foreign capital great. These foreign banking corporations had been established in the preceding decades then saw the opportunity to quickly expand their business in China to meet the Chinese government's demands. By the end of the 19th century there was a total number of 19 foreign banks operating in China with 101 branches spread all over the important trading cities of the country. These foreign bank corporations enjoyed the protection of extraterritoriality laws and were able to issue their own banknotes to circulate within Qing territory, have the ability to take in large deposits, and be trusted to manage the Maritime Customs revenue and Chinese government transfers. These foreign banks also served as acting receiving agents for war indemnities which were owed by the Qing government to foreign nations. The largest loans that were negotiated under the Chinese "borrowing foreign capital" policy were through the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation. Between the years 1895 and 1911 HSBC concluded a total of 112 loans to the government of the Qing dynasty which were worth 1,806,000,000 silver dollars.
Of paramount principle among the business interests of the Chinese government during the Qing dynasty was the financing of 2,800 miles of newly constructed railroads in the Yangtze valley. All these expensive loans with the various foreign banking corporations were secured by China's salt tax as well as Chinese customs revenues. By making so many loans to the Chinese government, the foreign banking companies were able to establish what were essentially "spheres of influence" in different regions of China, with the Russians in the northeast (specifically Manchuria), the United Kingdom enjoyed more influence in the Yangtze valley, the Japanese Empire exercised their influence in the northern and central regions of China, and the French were more influential the southern regions.
From the mid-nineteenth century up to the beginning of World War II, no fewer than twelve foreign countries maintained banks in China. Due to a large number of unequal treaties foreign banks enjoyed extraterritoriality rights when operating in China, which also included the freedom to issue their own banknotes. The influx of foreign banks into China also brought with them a new type of financing which became an inspiration for Chinese entrepreneurs to found similar financial institutions in China itself; some of these were government-owned institutions, while others were privately run. These institutions were the made up of following banks:
- Commercial Bank of China (中國通商銀行);
- Ta-Ching Government Bank (大清銀行);
- Bank of Communications (交通銀行);
- Ningpo Commercial Bank (四明銀行);
- Bank of Territorial Development (殖邊銀行);
- Che Kiang Bank (浙江銀行) in Zhejiang;
- Baoshan Yinhang (寶善銀行) in Beijing,
- Chinese Mercantile Bank (華商通業銀行) in Yangzhou.
Despite the fact that the number of these banks was not that very high, their business proved to have a great impact on the modernisation of the financial and monetary system of China during the late imperial and the early Republican era. Even certain government-owned institutions like the railway corporations can be seen as modern credit institutes because they issued their own modernised paper money.
An alternative narrative argues that privately issued banknotes by native banks and local money shops had become a fundamental in the late-Imperial Chinese currency system a long time before the entry of Western banking corporations into China during late 1840s. An important hypothesis of this alternative narrative speculates that the Chinese population at the time did not trust government-issued banknotes, while banknotes issued by established private banks, shops and financiers tended to be well accepted by the general populace.
By the end of the 19th century provincial governments started setting up their own note issuing banks like the Hupeh Provincial Bank (湖北官錢局, Hubei Guan-Qianju) with branches in Wuchang and Hankou, the Hubei Guan-Qianju issued a series of banknotes known as the Hubei Guanpiao (湖北官票). These banknotes were denominated in taels for silver and strings for copper-alloy cash coins. The Hubei Guanpiao was abolished over a decade after the fall of the Qing dynasty in 1927 with the bankruptcy of the Hubei Guan-Qianju.
China signed the Mackay Treaty with the United Kingdom on 5 September 1902. This treaty included a provision where the imperial Chinese government would create a uniform coinage "which shall be legal tender in payment of all duties taxes and other obligations throughout the Empire by British and Chinese subjects". The idea behind this provision was to remove obstacles for trading in the form of a very diverse coinage system throughout China. The reality was that subsidiary production of coinage was not so lucrative to begin with. Despite the provisions set for creating a uniform coinage the treaty made no reference to banknotes. During this era both local and foreign businesses demanded the creation of a uniform Chinese currency system, which would not occur during the Qing dynasty era. There was a major question at the time whether this uniform currency system would be placed on the silver standard or the gold standard. The introduction of a uniform currency also meant that the responsibility over monetary affairs would be completely transferred over to the hands of the imperial government which at the time was heavily in debt and did not have any grip on its own finances.
Establishing a national bank
During the later part of the Qing dynasty era there was a discussion on whether or not the imperial Chinese government would have to establish a national bank which it finally did in 1905. Peng Shu (彭述) stated before the introduction of new banknotes that the national bank would have to keep sufficient reserves in "touchable" money (現金) at all times. The large number of private notes that were being produced all over the empire was to be restricted by introducing a stamp duty (印花稅). The reformer Liang Qichao campaigned for the government of the Qing dynasty to emulate the Western world and Japan by embracing the gold standard, unify refractory the currencies of China, and issue government-backed banknotes with a ⅓ metallic reserve. At the end of 1905 the Ta-Ching Bank of the Ministry of Revenue (大清戶部銀行) was founded, and the production of the banknotes was entrusted to the prints of the Beiyang Newspaper (北洋報局) in Northern China. In 1906 the government of the Qing dynasty sent students to Japan to be educated about modern printing techniques, with the aim to have the Shanghai Commercial Press (上海商務印書館) print the cheques of the Ministry's Bank. The Ta-Ching Bank of the Ministry of Revenue were still issuing two different types of banknotes, one series was denominated in "tael", these were known as the Yinliang Piao (銀兩票) and had the denominations of 1 tael, 5 taels, 10 taels, 50 taels, and 100 taels. The other series was denominated in "yuan" and were known as Yinyuan Piao (銀元票) and were issued in the denominations of 1 yuan, 5 yuan, 10 yuan, 50 yuan, and 100 yuan. In the year 1907 the Ta-Ching Bank of the Ministry of Revenue was renamed to the Ta-Ching Government Bank (大清銀行), accordingly the inscription on all banknotes had to be changed to reflect this.
Following the Chinese tradition of issuing new money in a new reign, the Xuantong administration had the design of the official Ta-Ching Government Bank paper notes somewhat changed to herald in the new emperor. The new design was inspired by the designs of the banknotes of the United States dollar of this era; some banknotes showed the portrait of Li Hongzhang, and others depicted that of Zaifeng, Prince Chun who at the time was the current Chinese Minister of Finance. At the eve of the Xinhai Revolution in 1911, there were 5,400,000 tael worth of Yinliang banknotes circulating in China, and 12,400,000 yuan in Yinyuan banknotes.
List of banknotes denominated in copper-alloy cash coins issued during the Xianfeng era
List of banknotes denominated in copper-alloy cash coins issued during the Xianfeng era:
|Xianfeng cash notes (1853–1859)|
|Denomination||Years of production||Approximate size
|500 wén||Xianfeng 3, Xianfeng 4, Xianfeng 5, Xianfeng 6, Xianfeng 7, Xianfeng 8||130 x 232|
|1000 wén||Xianfeng 3, Xianfeng 4, Xianfeng 5, Xianfeng 6, Xianfeng 7, Xianfeng 8||138 x 240|
|1500 wén||Xianfeng 4||126 x 233|
|2000 wén||Xianfeng 3, Xianfeng 4, Xianfeng 5, Xianfeng 6, Xianfeng 7, Xianfeng 8, Xianfeng 9||138 x 245|
|5000 wén||Xianfeng 6, Xianfeng 7, Xianfeng 8, Xianfeng 9||138 x 247|
|10,000 wén||Xianfeng 7, Xianfeng 8, Xianfeng 9||141 x 248|
|50,000 wén||Xianfeng 7, Xianfeng 8, Xianfeng 9||147 x 267|
|100,000 wén||Xianfeng 7, Xianfeng 8, Xianfeng 9||145 x 277|
List of banknotes denominated in silver taels issued during the Xianfeng era
List of banknotes denominated in silver tael sycees issued during the Xianfeng era:
|Xianfeng tael notes (1853–1858)|
|Denomination||Years of production||Approximate size
|1 liǎng||Xianfeng 3, Xianfeng 4, Xianfeng 5, Xianfeng 6||151 x 250|
|3 liǎng||Xianfeng 3, Xianfeng 4, Xianfeng 5, Xianfeng 6, Xianfeng 7, Xianfeng 8||152 x 248|
|5 liǎng||Xianfeng 3, Xianfeng 4, Xianfeng 5, Xianfeng 6, Xianfeng 7||154 x 250|
|10 liǎng||Xianfeng 3, Xianfeng 4, Xianfeng 5, Xianfeng 6||190 x 315|
|50 liǎng||Xianfeng 3, Xianfeng 4, Xianfeng 5, Xianfeng 6||190 x 310|
Banknotes produced by Belgian banks
The Kingdom of Belgium, despite being a small country, was a state with a rather highly developed industrial base and also enjoyed being a centre of international trade during the later 19th and early 20th centuries. The Sino-Belgian Bank (French: Banque Sino-Belge) was founded by King Leopold for doing business in remittances and conducting international trade; the Sino-Belgian Bank belied its name because it did not have any indigenous Chinese participation at all, making it a purely Belgian company. Following the Boxer Rebellion in the year 1900 the Sino-Belgian Bank set up a branch in the city of Shanghai, where its primary business was in handling out long-term loans for the construction of railways in China. Other branches were later opened in the cities of Beijing, Tianjin, and Hankou. Belgium itself benefited from this as it exported materials to China, especially construction materials which were used for railroads. In the scramble for Chinese railroad concessions the Sino-Belgian Bank worked closely together with the Compagnie General de Chemins de Fer et de Tramways en Chine to issue bonds first in the year 1903 and later once more in the year 1913 these company bonds were used to finance Chinese railroad construction during the early 20th century.
The Sino-Belgian Bank issued banknotes in the year 1908 with the denominations of 1 dollar, 5 dollars, 10 dollars, and 50 dollars at all of its branches. These banknotes mostly circulated within the Shanghai International Settlement and the Shanghai French Concession.
In the year 1912 the Sino-Belgian Bank changed its name to the Banque Belge Pour l'Étranger. Banknotes issued after 1912 during the Republican period carried the new name of the bank to reflect this change. At the Shanghai International Settlement the circulation of paper notes was by the Banque Belge Pour l'Étranger never allowed to exceed 1,000,000 dollars.
The Sino-Belgian Bank/Banque Belge Pour l'Étranger enjoyed a positive reputation in China and its banknotes were at all times well received and could always easily redeemed at the bank's offices. The Banque Belge Pour l'Étranger was forced to cease its business when the Chinese republican government took over the Chinese economy from foreign management in the year 1935.
Banknotes produced by British banks
British banknotes in China during the Qing dynasty were by far the most common and the most highly esteemed of all banknotes of foreign origin circulating in China at the time. Early British banknotes that circulated in China became very influential for later Chinese banknotes and was essential for informing Chinese monetary thinking later in the 19th century and early 20th century.
Early British Indian banks in China
At one time or another there were never less than 15 British owned banks that did business in the Qing dynasty, seven of these banks were from the British Indian Empire. After the conclusions of the First and Second Opium Wars the United Kingdom forced a number of "unequal treaties" on the Qing demanding trade rights with several Chinese ports which became known as "treaty ports". Soon after these agreements were signed the leading merchant houses of British India, setting themselves up as private banks, pursued new sources of revenue in imperial China. Both the central and provincial governments held very little restraint in printing paper money during the Xianfeng period, this made it so that the Bund in the foreign concessions of Shanghai was one of the few places in China where paper money had actually been standardised. This also made the Bund was one of the few places where paper money could actually be exchanged for silver trade dollars or silver bullion of quality that could be verified without regard to the outside political climate. This situation wasn't much different in the city of Shanghai until the first British banks established offices there.
The first of these, the Oriental Bank Corporation, was quick to establish a branch in Qing territory. The Oriental Bank Corporation went bankrupt in 1884. The London-based Chartered Mercantile Bank of India, London and China opened branch in the British crown colony of Hong Kong in the year 1845 and some time after the establishment of this branch commenced issuing banknotes denominated in Spanish milled dollars. This series of paper notes was based upon the Carlos silver dollar, which at the time was the generally preferred medium of exchange among Chinese merchants. The Chartered Mercantile Bank of India, London and China later opened a branch in the British concession of the port city of Shanghai in October of the year 1854, where they issued both silver dollar and tael banknotes.
Between the years 1845 and 1866 many other British banks that were based in India started setting up offices in cities along the coastline of China such as Guangzhou and Hong Kong along the Pearl River Delta and the city of Shanghai which lies along the Yangtze River Delta. Among these Indian-based banks were the Agra and United Services Bank (which was established in the year 1853, but went bankrupt in 1866), the Asiatic Banking Corporation, the Chartered Mercantile Bank of India, London and China (which was established in the year 1853), the Bank of Hindustan, China and Japan, and the Chartered Bank of India, Australia and China (which was established in the year 1857). The Comptoir d'Escompte de Paris from France also started operating in China during this era. These banks functioned as the main financiers of contemporary trade between the Far East (especially Qing China) and the West (Europe, North America, South America, and Australia). By the year 1866 these early British banks had all opened up branches in the Chinese harbour towns of Hankou, Hong Kong, and Shanghai, geographic position of the latter of these ports gave it a particularly advantageous position as it is located in the Yangtze River Delta and the Grand Canal meaning that goods that go through this port would be able to reach the entirety of China. The offices of these banks were all concentrated in an area of Shanghai known as the Bund. In the beginning the need for the services of these foreign banks in China was restricted to only trade opium from British India into Chinese territory and exports of Chinese tea to markets across the entire world. Because the time that tea could be exported was a period that lasted for during the summer months and as opium imports became increasingly restricted by the government of the Qing dynasty, many of these early Anglo-Indian banks in China went bankrupt or had to be reorganised.
The Oriental Bank Corporation which was the first foreign bank to conduct its business in China by opening a local branch also opened up a branch in the Bund where it then started issuing its own banknotes. The British-owned Chartered Mercantile Bank of India, London and China which issued the banknotes of the Hong Kong dollar from the year 1859 until 1892 was later reorganised as the Mercantile Bank of India and stopped operating in China. After the fall of the Qing dynasty and when the Republic of China's rule over the mainland came to an end the only British Indian bank still operating in China was the Chartered Bank of India, Australia and China.
The Asiatic Banking Corporation had become dependent on its trade with the Confederate States of America (CSA) and eventually tied its fate to the success of this nation which lost its war of independence in 1865. At the time of the American Civil War the textile mills of the United Kingdom were wholly dependent upon cotton shipped from the Confederate States of America. However the Confederates did not wish to supply cotton to the British unless they were seen as a recognised state which the British government refused, because of this the British decided to invest more into the cotton industry of India and Ceylon attempting to create a whole cotton raising culture overnight to make up for the lack of Confederate cotton. The price of cotton in the United Kingdom went up immensely as the demand could not be met with the supply. Speculation in cotton futures at the time started to run rife, of these futures the Asiatic Bank was the principal provider of capital.
After the American Civil War ended with a decisive victory for the United States of America in 1865 the Asiatic Bank had to close its doors in 1866 as the cheap cotton from the Southern United States was freely available on the British market again ending the experiment with the production of cotton in British India and Ceylon. All banknotes issued by the Asiatic Bank to circulate in Qing China had an identical design but had different branch names on them.
The banknotes issued by these early Anglo-Indian banks which did business in the Qing dynasty between the years 1845 and 1870 are today exceedingly rare to find and are only seldom offered making them beyond the reach of the average banknote collector due to their scarcity. The quantity of paper money channeled into Chinese monetary traffic by these Anglo-Indian banks was comparatively small and in some cases exceedingly minor which explains their current rarity.
Later British banks
The second biggest British bank in China was during the Qing dynasty was the Chartered Bank of India, Australia and China, which was originally formed in British India by a Royal Charter issued under the reign of Queen Victoria of the United Kingdom in the year 1857. In 1858 the Chartered Bank of India, Australia and China opened an office in the British crown colony of Hong Kong and in 1861 the Chartered Bank of India, Australia and China was granted the right to issue banknotes for Hong Kong. Sizable portions of some of its early business involved the discounting of bills for the export of the narcotic opium from British India to the Qing dynasty which generated a significant number of profit.
From the year 1861 the Chartered Bank of India, Australia and China was granted the ability to produce "Notes Payable to Bearer on Demand" at all of their offices. The banknotes produced by the Chartered Bank of India, Australia and China were at all times within the safeguards obligated by the colonial British banking regulations and were generally met with great acceptance in Hong Kong and China, with the a notable exception being the city of Shanghai, where the local Han Chinese population was known for holding a prejudice against foreign produced paper money. This negative perception of foreign paper money was in part because of the refusal of the imperial Chinese Customs House stationed there to accept them as valid currency in payment of dues. As a result of this negative bias by the authorities, there was never a large amount of foreign banknotes in circulation in Shanghai. With the sole exception of Shanghai, the fiat money issued by the Chartered Bank of India, Australia and China, which may have been circulating in small quantities, enjoyed being highly regarded by the Chinese public.
The National Bank of China Limited was an institution of which today only very little is known. The very existence of this bank would not have been known if it weren't for the discovery of several salesman's samples in the beginning of the 21st century which mention its existence. It is known to have been operating in British Hong Kong with an additional branch in the city of Shanghai. Richard von Glahn reports that the National Bank of China Limited was established by the British in colonial Hong Kong in the year 1891 and disbanded in the year 1911. At the time of its disestablishment the National Bank of China Limited had a minor amount of paid up capital worth only £600,000. The banknotes of this bank in circulation were always small in number. Upon closing its doors permanently all banknotes produced by the bank seemed to have been fully accounted for, which is a most unusual thing to happen in China; this explains the virtual non-existence of the National Bank of China Limited today.
The central government of the Qing dynasty only attempted to regulate Chinese banks and its currency near the end of the dynasty. By the time that the Qing started finally implementing financial reforms China was beholden to mercy of foreign powers; because of this the issue of foreign banknotes in China and restrictions on foreign banking and foreign banks (including British banks) in general were generally not made.
The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation
The banknotes produced by the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation (HSBC) had seen extensive circulation in the territory of the Qing dynasty from the 1870s and later. In the year 1864 the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation was established by the Scottish Thomas Sutherland to finance Far East trade and would later grow to become both the largest and most influential of all the foreign banks during the Qing dynasty era. The Traditional Chinese characters for the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation were "匯豐銀行" (Huifeng Yinhang, which the British pronounced as "Wayfung"). These Chinese characters could be translated as "abundant remittances".
Over the following years the HSBC became a banking leader in East and Southeast Asia. This happened because the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation was a key player in many major events in the region, such as acting as banker for the Hong Kong government from 1880 onwards, establishing the first bank in the Kingdom of Siam in the year 1888 where it printed the first banknotes of the Siamese tical, and overseeing the management of British colonial government accounts in Qing China, Japan, Singapore, and other areas of influence. In an advertisement in the North-China Herald of 17 February 1876 the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation reported to have a paid up capital of five million dollars and a reserved fund of one hundred thousand dollars while at the time it operated branches in eight different countries, while in China it had branches in Beijing, Tianjin, Shanghai, Hankou, Fuzhou, Yantai, and Xiamen.
The quantity of banknotes of the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation made the amounts produced by other foreign banking corporations in China at the time look minuscule when compared. The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation produced the banknotes of the Hong Kong dollar during its colonial era.
The Shanghai branch of the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation was established only briefly after the bank opened its headquarters in the British colony of Hong Kong. The General Manager of the Shanghai branch was a Scotsman named David MacLean who fulfilled his role between the years 1865 and 1873 and managed to convince the Chinese Imperial Maritime Customs to deposit all its incoming revenue with the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation which proved to be a very profitable endeavour for the British bank. HSBC soon established new branches wherever the Imperial Maritime Customs had one of its local offices. Afterwards the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation would find itself branching out beyond customs as it would expand in the businesses of money deposits and lending money to the Chinese government, collect war indemnities on behalf of the British government, finance the construction of railways, and lending money to the military of the Qing dynasty which was fighting an expensive campaign against warlords in the north of China. The many branches of the bank issued their own banknotes which due to the position and positive reputation of the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation were in great demand across China.
During the 19th century until the break out of World War I the United Kingdom closely cooperated with the German Empire in China to balance out the expansionist influences of the French and Russian spheres of interest in China, s the result the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation worked closely and very successfully with the Deutsch-Asiatische Bank. By the turn of the 20th century HSBC had become the most important foreign banking company in imperial China leading to a great variety of banknotes being issued by the bank during this era. As the shareholders of the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation had only very limited liability for the banknotes emissed by the company, HSBC was required to hold ⅓ specie reserve in their vaults at any given time. Thus resulted in the fact these banknotes were always secured to be paid out to the bearer and never faced being defaulted.
The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation had effectively set the Shanghai foreign currency exchange rates are a fact which shows the extent of its sizable and growing dominant role in Chinese financial matters during the Qing dynasty and early Republican eras. The role of the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation as custodian of the official finds of the Chinese government would continue until this task was assumed by the Central Bank of China and responsibilities were handled by the Chinese themselves, this was done after the Chinese currency reform enacted in the year 1935.
Banknotes produced by French banks
Prior to the outbreak of the first world war the French operated two banking corporations in China which were granted banknote issue rights by the Chinese government; these were the Banque de l'Indochine and the Banque Industrielle de Chine.
Banque de l'Indochine
The Banque de l’Indochine was created in the year 1898 to serve as the financial arm of France in Southeast Asia and more particularly in French Indochina. After the turn of the century in 1900 the business interests of the Banque de l’Indochine was shifted from India to focus more on the Chinese market, particularly in Southern China. In China the Banque de l’Indochine collected war indemnities for the Boxer Rebellion on behalf of the French government, where it served as the sole French representative in handling the Boxer indemnity. After "the French sphere of influence" established in China as southern China, the Banque de l'Indochine was tasked with taking over international trade between the French Republic and all of Qing China. In addition to its monopoly on issuing banknotes in French Indochina the Banque de l’Indochine also circulated its banknotes in neighbouring Chinese provinces, most notably in the provinces of Yunnan and Guizhou. The Banque de l'Indochine assigned a position of priority in the financing of the infrastructure of the French concession in Shanghai's International Settlement, where some if its notable accomplishments include the Shanghai Electric Power Company and the Shanghai Tramways.
The Banque de l’Indochine opened its first branch in China in 1899 in Shanghai and quickly opened more branches in Beijing, Hankou, Kunming, and Tianjin. All of these branches produced banknotes denominated in "dollars" for local circulation in China. At the Shanghai branch the French had made an attempt at issuing banknotes denominated in "taels" but this programme was almost immediately abandoned as non-remunerative. The banknotes produced by the Banque de l'Indochine were tri-lingual, printed in the French, English, and Mandarin Chinese languages making them the only foreign bank to employ three languages on their paper money in China. Denominations on banknotes produced by the Banque de l’Indochine were described in both French francs and Mexican piastres. These banknotes circulated in relatively small quantities in China until the year 1940, and consequently tend to be quite rare today.
Banknotes produced by Japanese banks
Bank of Taiwan
After the First Sino-Japanese War ended the Chinese were forced to give up the island of Taiwan to the Japanese as a part of the Treaty of Shimonoseki. Under Japanese rule the island was being run as a colony and soon Japanese institutions were being established for the benefit of the Empire of Japan. In the year 1899 the Bank of Taiwan was established and had a starting capital of ¥ 5,000,000. The goals of the Bank of Taiwan were to provide capital for the export of Taiwanese raw materials to Japan proper and to expand Japanese trade with China through its branch offices in Mainland China. The first mainland Chinese branch of the Bank of Taiwan was opened in Shanghai where in 1905 it issued a series of banknotes denominated in "Silver dollars". The issuing of these paper notes a5lsp required permission from the imperial Japanese government. In 1906 a series of banknotes were issued consisting of the denominations 1 gold yen, 5 gold yen, 10 gold yen, 50 gold yen, and 100 gold yen.
The designs of the banknotes of the Bank of Taiwan were not uniform nor were their sizes; the designs of these banknotes seems to have been dictated by local Chinese customs. Some had a vertical design such as the banknotes produced by the Xiamen (Amoy) and Shantou (Swatow) branches, while those produced at the Guangzhou (Canton), Hankou, Jiujiang, Shanghai, and Fuzhou branches were all horizontal, although the general shape of the banknotes and their design patterns also differ between branches.
An approximate 10% of all banknotes produced by the Japanese Bank of Taiwan were circulating on mainland China at any given time.
Yokohama Specie Bank
The only truly Japanese banking company to circulate its own banknotes in Qing dynasty era China was the Yokohama Specie Bank. The Yokohama Specie Bank was established in the year 1880 for the international trade Japan had recently been opened to, the bank primarily did business in discounting bills of exchange, handling in the Japanese foreign exchange market, and in promoting trade with the Chinese Empire. In the year 1893 the Yokohama Specie Bank opened an office in the Chinese trade port of Shanghai.
During the early years of the Yokohama Specie Bank it had survived an economic recession, after which the Yokohama Specie Bank received loans from the imperial Japanese government and permission to issue its own paper notes. At first the bank used the silver standard was used to back the banknotes it put into circulation but, due to global depreciation of silver during the late 19th century, the Meiji period imperial Japanese government had turned to use the gold standard for its currency in the year 1897, using the war indemnity money due to them after the defeat of the Qing dynasty in the First Sino-Japanese War as backing for the new gold yen banknotes.
After the first Sino-Japanese and Russo-Japanese Wars the Yokohama Specie Bank shifted its focus northwards to Manchuria where it first took over the grain trade from the Chinese and later the railroad activities from the Russians. The branch offices of the Yokohama Specie Bank tasked with producing banknotes in Manchuria were located at Dairen, Harbin, Yingkou (Newchwang), Tsinan, Liaoyang, Mukden, and Tiehling, these offices were initially established in support of Japanese military personnel stationed in Manchuria. Additional branches of the Yokohama Specie Bank in China were located in Beijing, Tianjin, Qingdao, Shanghai, and Hankou. Although the issues of paper money by the bank were small and managed in a good manner, the banknotes principally served the Japanese population in China and Manchuria, as the Chinese people rejected them due to resentments they harboured over the Japanese encroachment in their country.
The 1903 silver yen notes produced by the Niuzhuang branch played an important role in financing local soy bean production in the region of Manchuria. By the year 1907 the Yokohama Specie Bank's paper notes enjoyed circulation throughout all of Manchuria. These banknotes were circulated by the branch in the port city of Dairen. Peak circulation of the Yokohama Specie Bank's paper notes was reached in the year 1911 when a total 7,200,000 dollars its banknotes were paid out.
Over its many years of operating in China the Yokohama Specie Bank issued a large variety of paper notes. At different times it issued banknotes that were denominated in taels, dollars, silver yen, gold yen, big money, small money, local currency and even fractional small denominational sen notes. All banknotes produced by the Yokohama Specie Bank were printed by the Printing Bureau of the Imperial Japanese Government.
Today all banknotes produced by the Yokohama Specie Bank during the late Qing dynasty period between 1902 and 1911 are rare and bring exceedingly high prices on the private collectors market, the sole exception to this rule being the 1 dollar banknote which was issued in 1902, this banknote occasionally becomes available to collectors. In general Yokohama Specie Bank varieties provide private collectors with a rather wide field from which they could build up a notaphilic collection. The problem many collectors of banknotes today face is that, due to tight management by the Japanese and a near total banknote redemption, very few of these paper notes remained unredeemed making them relatively rare today.
Banknotes produced by Russian banks
The Russo-Chinese Bank (華俄道勝銀行) was founded on December 5, 1895 in the Russian Embassy in Paris as a joint-venture, from Russian and French capital. Approximately a year after it was established the Russo-Chinese Bank received a contract from the government of the Qing dynasty for the construction of the Chinese Eastern Railway in the three provinces making up Manchuria. This venture into Manchurian railways proved to be so successful that by the end of the year 1902 the Russo-Chinese Bank had achieved the status of being the 2nd largest foreign banking corporation in all of the Chinese Empire. The total of all British bank investment in the year 1902 (including the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation), added up to 33% of the investments from foreign banks into the Chinese economy, while the Russo-Chinese Bank by itself managed to account for as much as 31.3%. The different branches of the Russo-Chinese Bank each fulfilled different roles as the Beijing office was basically exclusively engaged in political affairs with the imperial Chinese government while the Shanghai office was mostly invested in the mercantile exchange business.
The Russo-Chinese bank enjoyed a large amount of prosperity from its Manchurian railroad charter which allowed the bank to issue two series of banknotes; in the year 1901 it issued banknotes denominated in "Mexican dollars" and a second series was issued in the year 1907 denominated in "Taels". After the Chinese Eastern Railway started opening up for business the Russo-Chinese Bank collected the fares for both passengers and goods in Mexican pesos. However after the railway was fully operational the company preferred to exclusively handle fees in Russian rubles. As an effect of the Russo-Japanese War the Russo-Chinese Bank lost a majority of its funds as it had invested heavily into the Russian military leading it to merge with various other imperial Russian banking companies operating in China and the Banque du Nord in 1910 becoming the Russo-Asiatic Bank.
The Russo-Asiatic Bank was created in the year 1910 out of a series of mergers of the Russo-Chinese Bank with other banks during a reorganisation. This change was fundamentally only a rename as all of its outstanding assets and its business, after the deduction of its war losses, remained completely intact. Under the Russo-Chinese Bank name the bank never enjoyed a large paper note circulation, which is attested by the fact that according to the bank's final balance sheet, published by the bank's St. Petersburg headquarters, showed the number of banknotes remaining in circulation, outstanding, and unredeemed to be total of only 146,177 banknotes in dollars and 13,766 banknotes in taels. Banknotes that still had the old name of the bank (Russo-Chinese Bank) in circulation had the name crossed out by hand by employees of the bank. After the Bolsheviks took Russia by revolution in the year 1918, they nationalised all of the Russo-Asiatic Bank's properties in the country partially because the bank had supported the White Russians against the Bolshevik state. After this the bank moves its headquarters to Paris where it would go bankrupt in 1926 after losing £ 5,000,000 while speculating in foreign currency at the Paris financial markets. The Paris branch office then sent out a notification to the Shanghai branch office to close the doors of the establishment forever ending the Russo-Asiatic Bank's operations in China.
Banknotes produced by the East Turkestan branches of the Russo-Asiatic Bank (Kashgar, Yining, and Changuchak) during the Republican period circulating between the years 1913 and 1924 still prominently depicted imperial Chinese symbols such as the five-fingered dragon on both sides. They were the distinguished from banknotes produced by other foreign banking corporations because they were denominated in fixed weights of pure gold, rather that specific monetary units. The banknotes from this era were printed by Bradbury Wilkinson and Company in London, United Kingdom.
The Deutsch-Asiatische Bank was created on 15 May 1889 and was notable for being the first major non-British foreign banking corporation in China during the Qing dynasty period, and was notable for being the only German bank with the right to issue its own notes in China. The main priority for the Deutsch-Asiatische Bank was to finance imperials loans requested by the Qing government with a special focus on both railways and mining operations within the sphere of interest held by the German Empire in the province of Shandong. The initial capital the Deutsch-Asiatische Bank paid up to the government of the Qing dynasty numbered at 5,000,000 taels, a number which would steadily increase as time goes by. In the year 1896 the Deutsch-Asiatische Bank entered a cooperation with the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation (HSBC) to underwrite Chinese government loans aggregating £32,000,000. The money for these government loans was secured by collectig the revenue of the Imperial Maritime Customs and taxes collected on Chinese salt. The project, which cost 54,000,000 gold mark, lead to the construction of 255 miles of railways from the city of Qingdao, German Kiautschou to Tsinan. Additionally it paid 12,000,000 gold mark for the establishment of new mining operations in Shandong. The Deutsch-Asiatische Bank was later also involved with British, French and Russian interests to build railways outside of the German sphere of interest. The banknotes issued by the Deutsch-Asiatische Bank were denominated in silver taels and silver dollars. The paper money that the bank was allowed to bring into circulation was tightly controlled by the German imperial government in Berlin and it was always in small quantities. The initial emission of banknotes occurred in the year 1907 and was strictly controlled by the German government, well managed, and in great demand. The second issue occurred during the Republic of China in the year 1914 after the banknotes arrived shortly before the Japanese invasion during World War I. Because of the war only a small number of banknotes actually entered circulation. Although the banknotes of the DAB had no printer's imprint on them, it was generally believed that they were produced in the Leipzig plant of the German printer company Giesecke+Devrient. All banknotes produced by this bank depict German national personification German alongside the imperial German eagle and a Chinese dragon prominently displayed on them.
After the outbreak of World War I, the Deutsch-Asiatische Bank was forced to suspend its operations in China. At the time that it had to cease operating in China an amount of 2,595,968 taels worth of banknotes was circulating at the time. In the year 1917 the Chinese republican government revoked the bank's privilege to produce its own paper notes for the Chinese market.
International Banking Corporation
The sole American bank to operate in imperial China was the New York City based International Banking Corporation, which was founded on 1 December 1901 for the purpose of promoting foreign trade with the United States in China and had two series of banknotes issued during both the Qing dynasty and early Republican periods. As the flag of the United States flew over the bank's several branch offices in China, the Chinese people began referring to the red, white, and blue coloured standard as "Hua-qi" (華旗, "colourful flag"), and it wasn't long before the International Banking Corporation itself was referred to as "Huaqi Yinhang" (華旗銀行, "colourful flag bank") by the people of China.
American banking companies did not do business in the Chinese banking field until the very beginning of the 20th century. With none of their own banks in imperial China, all trade remittances of the United States had to go through British banks operating in the country. American Secretary of State John Hay advocated for the Americans to get involved in the Chinese market and obtain a share of it. As the United States had joined the eight-power alliance to put down the Boxer Rebellion in 1900, Americans felt it only right that they also participate in their share of the Boxer indemnities awarded to foreign powers in China. The first branch office of the International Banking Corporation in China was opened in Shanghai in 1902. In addition to dealing with the Boxer indemnities, the International Banking Corporation was active in granting loans to the government of the Qing dynasty, the largest of these loans being the Huguang Railway loan of 1911. In the year 1915 the National City Bank of New York had acquired a majority of shares in the International Banking Corporation. On 1 January 1927 the International Banking Corporation was to be entirely superseded by the National City Bank of New York, who took over all branch offices and would continue to operate them under its own brand name.
The banknotes issued by the International Banking Corporation were denominated in "local currency" and were released in the denominations of 1 dollar, 5 dollars, 10 dollars, 50 dollars, and 100 dollars in the year 1907. All banknotes featured a pair of globes depicting both the eastern and western hemispheres, an American eagle, and the scales of Justice. In the first year of its business the International Banking Corporation issued banknotes into circulation worth 202,474 dollars, later increasing this amount to 477,760 at the end of the Qing dynasty period by 1912. During the early Republican era a series of banknotes was released in 1918 which were denominated in "taels".
The old paper notes issued by the International Banking Corporation were very popular in China and in great demand, and were always redeemed by the bank without being discounted as was very common for other institutions. When called in, the banknotes were canceled by the bank by cutting them in half. Many banknotes of the International Banking Corporation today found in collections were altered by gluing the two halves together and tend to bear mismatched serial numbers as a result; these banknotes are worth very little when compared to unaltered specimens found today.
Netherlands Trading Society
The Netherlands Trading Society (Dutch: Nederlandsche Handel-Maatschappij or NHM) created its first branch office in China in the year 1903 on the Bund in the port city of Shanghai. In comparison with other foreign banking corporations operating in China the Netherlands Trading Society was not a large banking company. However the bank handled a large variety of different trade businesses with the Chinese. While the Netherlands Trading Society's presence in China was small or served as a training base for the future generation of Chinese bankers, many of these native businessmen later went on to form their own private banking companies during the Qing and Republican eras.
The number of banknotes produced by the Netherlands Trading Society in circulation in China was at all times relatively small in quantity because Dutch law had a substantial requirement for reserves to be held to back up the paper money issued that went into circulation. In the year 1909 the Netherlands Trading Society issued banknotes with the denominations 1 dollar, 5 dollars, and 10 dollars and later under the Republic of China government in 1922 banknotes with the denominations of 100 dollars and 500 dollars were issued. All banknotes issued by the Netherlands Trading Society in China had a principal vignette that depicted a Chinese warrior bearing a sword, clad in Chinese armour, and an ancient stone bridge.
Denominations used on paper money during the late Qing period
The denominations of the contemporary coinage was extremely chaotic with different standards being used across regions, making it a confusing mess to exchange between areas due to the wide range of systems and denominations used to categorise the many coinages of the Qing. There was likewise a wide range of types of paper notes. The traditional copper-allow cash was reflected in cash notes (錢票). Some of these banknotes used the traditional government mandated exchange rate of 1,000 wén per string of cash coins (吊), while others used differing local exchange rates, like the Eastern cash or Dongqian (東錢) of the Fengtian province, with 160 cash coins per string, or the metropolitan cash (京錢) from Beijing which had an exchange rate of 500 cash coins per string. Local banknotes usually reflected local exchange rates.
On the local markets, the exchange rates even deviated from the fixed denominations, as had been the case with cash coins of substandard quality for an extended amount of time. The silver currency was reflected in silver notes (銀票), and also in other types of paper money, there were great differences in the conversion rate depending on the region where the banknotes were traded or used in. In Beijing, the imperial Kuping tael (庫平兩) exchange rate was used side by side with the local metropolitan rate which was known as the Jingping Liang (京平兩), while the Shanghai tael (上海紋銀) was used on banknotes issued by both the Huifeng Bank (匯豐銀行) and the Shanghai Tongshang Yinhang (上海通商銀行). The banknotes of the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation were principally denominated in "Chinese dollars"; however, the tael, Mexican dollar, and various currencies based upon the local Chinese dollar were also employed as denominations.
The denominations on the silver yuan banknotes (銀元票) were the most standardised, but exchange rates still differed on the individual Chinese markets where they circulated, depending on the local value of the silver yuan coins. The imperial government attempted to clarify this chaotic situation with the Statutes for Paper Bills (通用銀錢票章程) decreed in the year 1909.
Denominations on banknotes of foreign banks in Qing China
|Foreign bank||Country of origin||Branche(s) in China
(or Hong Kong or Macau)
|Date(s) of issue||Denominations|
|Agra and United Services Bank||United Kingdom||Hong Kong||1862||100 dollars, 200 dollars, 300 dollars, 500 dollars|
|Asiatic Banking Corporation||United Kingdom||Shanghai||18xx||10 taels, 25 taels|
|Chartered Mercantile Bank of India, London and China||United Kingdom||Hankou,
|5 taels, 10 taels, 25 taels, 50 taels, 100 taels, 1000 taels,|
1 Mexican dollar, 5 Mexican dollars, 10 Mexican dollars, 50 Mexican dollars
|Chartered Bank of India, Australia and China||United Kingdom||Hankou,
|5 taels, 10 taels, 25 taels, 50 taels, 100 taels,|
1 Mexican dollar, 5 Mexican dollars, 10 Mexican dollars, 50 Mexican dollars,
1 Mexican dollar, 5 Mexican dollars, 10 Mexican dollars, 50 Mexican dollars, 100 Mexican dollars,
100 taels, 500 taels,
5 Hongping taels, 10 Hongping taels,
1 dollar, 5 dollars, 10 dollars, 25 dollars, 50 dollars, 100 dollars, 500 dollars
|Comptoir d'Escompte de Paris||France||Shanghai||1866||5 taels|
|Bank of Hindustan, China and Japan||United Kingdom||Hong Kong||1863||Unknown denominations|
|Hong Kong and Shanghai Banking Corporation (HSBC)||United Kingdom||Xiamen (Amoy),
|1 taels, 5 taels, 10 taels,|
1 Mexican dollars, 25 Mexican dollars, 50 Mexican dollars, 100 Mexican dollars,
1 tael, 5 taels, 10 taels, 50 taels, 100 taels,
1 dollar, 5 dollars, 10 dollars, 25 dollars, 50 dollars, 100 dollars
|National Bank of China||United Kingdom||Xiamen (Amoy),
|1892–1911||5 dollars, 10 dollars, 50 dollars, 100 dollars, 500 dollars|
|Oriental Bank Corporation||United Kingdom||Hong Kong,
|5 taels, 10 taels, 50 taels, 100 taels, 500 taels,|
5 dollars, 25 dollars, 50 dollars, 100 dollars
|100 cash, 300 cash,|
1 tael, 3 taels, 5 taels, 10 taels, 50 taels, 100 taels, 500 taels,
1 dollars, 5 dollars, 10 dollars, 50 dollars,
1 Mexican dollar, 5 Mexican dollars, 10 Mexican dollars, 50 Mexican dollars, 100 Mexican dollars
|1 dollar, 5 dollars, 10 dollars, 50 dollars, 100 dollars, 500 dollars,|
50 kopeks, 1 rouble, 3 roubles, 10 roubles, 100 roubles,
1 gold fen,[b] 2 gold fen, 10 gold fen, 50 gold fen, 100 gold fen,
1 Mexican dollar, 5 Mexican dollars, 10 Mexican dollars, 50 Mexican dollars, 100 Mexican dollars,
500 roubles, 1000 roubles
|1 dollar, 5 dollars, 10 dollars, 50 dollars,|
5 Mexican dollars, 10 Mexican dollars
|Bank Belge Pour l'Etranger
|1 dollar/piastre, 5 dollars/piastres, 10 dollars/piastres, 50 dollars/piastres, 100 dollars/piastres,|
5 Mexican dollars
|British and Belgian Industrial Bank of China||United Kingdom,
|Changsha||1912||5 taels, 10 taels|
Qingdao (Kiautschou Bay concession)
|1 tael, 5 taels, 10 taels, 20 taels,|
1 dollar, 5 dollars, 10 dollars, 25 dollars, 50 dollars,
100 dollars, 200 dollars,
50 taels, 100 taels, 500 taels
|International Banking Corporation||United States||Guangzhou (Canton),
|1 dollar, 5 dollars, 10 dollars, 50 dollars, 100 dollars,|
1 tael, 5 taels, 10 taels, 50 taels, 100 taels
|Banque de l'Indochine||France||Guangzhou (Canton),
|1901–1902||1 dollars/piastres, 5 dollars/piastres, 10 dollars/piastres, 100 dollars/piastres|
|Banco Nacional Ultramarino||Portugal||Macau||1905–1942,
|1 pataca, 5 patacas, 10 patacas, 25 patacas, 50 patacas, 100 patacas,|
1 avo, 5 avos, 10 avos, 20 avos, 50 avos
|Netherlands Trading Society||The Netherlands||Shanghai||1909,
|1 dollar, 5 dollars, 10 dollars,|
50 dollars, 100 dollars
|Bank of Taiwan, Ltd.||Japan||Xiamen (Amoy),
|1 silver yen, 5 silver yen, 10 silver yen, 50 silver yen,|
1 gold yen, 5 gold yen, 10 gold yen, 50 gold yen,
1 dollar, 5 dollars, 10 dollars, 50 dollars
|Yokohama Specie Bank, Ltd.||Japan||Dalian,
|5 taels, 10 taels, 50 taels, 100 taels,|
1 gold yen, 5 gold yen, 10 gold yen, 100 gold yen,
10 sen, 50 sen,
1 dollar, 5 dollars, 10 dollars, 50 dollars, 100 dollars
Banknotes as a percentage of the Chinese money stock during the late Qing dynasty
Chinese historian Peng Xinwei stated that in the year 1900 privately-produced banknotes made up only 3% of the total volume of Chinese currency stock. This number would (according to Niv Horesh) be unlikely to surpass 6% if banknotes denominated in silver currencies were taken into account (these banknotes were produced by government banks and modern banking corporations). Foreign banks operating in China generally did not disclose the volume of banknotes issued by them circulating in China proper; the fact that they did not openly disclose this resulted in inflated estimates thereof over the years. For this reason Horesh states that it would be very implausible to assume that the ratio of all banknotes as part of the entirety of the Chinese money stock was any significant number higher than 10% even as late as 1900.
Meanwhile during this same period the traditional cast copper-alloy cash coins would only make up 17.78% of the total Chinese currency stock; the percentage representing cash coins would only decrease from this point onwards. Meanwhile Peng estimated that foreign trade dollars circulating in China (which mostly included the silver Mexican peso) made up 25% of the total Chinese currency stock by the 1900s. This trend was actually the opposite in the Western world and Japan where the global introduction of government steam-minted coinages halted the spread of Mexican-mined silver pesos. This effect was most notable in North and South America as well as the Philippines. At the same time silver was being diffused from the gold standard and there were major discoveries of large silver deposits in the United States and West Africa.
- They were known by the first syllable of their names, hence they are known as "Yu banks" (宇).
- These banknotes were denominated in fixed weights of pure gold, rather than specific monetary units.
- Glahn, Richard von (2006). "Re-Examining the Authenticity of Song Paper Money Specimens", Journal of Song-Yuan Studies, 36: 79-106.
- Bernholz, Peter (1997). "Paper Money Inflation, Prices, Gresham's Law and Exchange Rates in Ming China", Kredit und Kapital, 30/1: 35-51.
- Chen, Chau-Nan, Chang Pin-Tsun, Chen, Shikuan. "The Sung and Ming Paper Monies: Currency Competition and Currency Bubbles", Journal of Macroeconomics, 17/2: 273-288.
- Li, Kangying (2007). "A Study on the Song, Yuan and Ming Monetary Policies against the Context of Worldwide Hard Currency Flows during the 11th-16th Centuries, and their Impact on Ming Institutions and Changes", in Angela Schottenhammer, ed. The East Asian Maritime World 1400-1800: Its Fabrics of Power and Dynamics of Exchanges (Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz), 99-136.
- Huang Da (黃達), Liu Hongru (劉鴻儒), Zhang Xiao (張肖), ed. (1990). Zhongguo jinrong baike quanshu (中國金融百科全書) (Beijing: Jingji guanli chubanshe), Vol. 1, 94. (in Mandarin Chinese)
- Wu Chouzhong (吳籌中) (1993). "Zhongguo gudai zhibi (中國古代紙幣)", in Zhongguo da baike quanshu (中國大百科全書), Wenwu boguguan 文物·博物館 (Beijing/Shanghai: Zhongguo da baike quanshu chubanshe), 784. (in Mandarin Chinese).
- Xie Tianyu (謝天宇), ed. (2005). Zhongguo qianbi shoucang yu jianshang quanshu (中國錢幣收藏與鑒賞全書) (Tianjin: Tianjin guji chubanshe), Vol. 2, 506, 508. (in Mandarin Chinese).
- Niv Horesh (28 September 2018). "The Monetary System of China under the Qing Dynasty". Springer Link. Retrieved 29 July 2019.
- Williams, S. Wells (1975). "Paper Money among the Chinese", T'ung Pao: Journal of the Society for Oriental Numismatics, 1/2: 38-40 [reprinted from The Chinese Repository, 20 (1851)].
- Rowe, William T. (2010). "Money, Economy, and Polity in the Daoguang-Era Paper Currency Debates", Late Imperial China, 31/2: 69-96.
- Kaske, Elisabeth (2015). "Silver, Copper, Rice and Debt: Monetary Policy and Office Selling in China during the Taiping Rebellion", in Jane Kate Leonard, Ulrich Theobald, ed. Money in Asia (1200 – 1900): Small Currencies in Social and Political Contexts (Leiden/Boston: Brill), pages 343–397.
- Rajeev Prasad (23 November 2012). "Did you know Series (14): Shanghai Museum :A treasure trove of ancient Chinese , Indian and Islamic coinage". Exclusivecoins.Blogspot.com. Retrieved 14 May 2019.
- Yang Lien-sheng (1954) Money and credit in China: a short history. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts, p. 68.
- Shi Yufu (石毓符) (1984) Zhongguo huobi jinrong shilüe (中國貨幣金融史略). Tianjin renmin chubanshe, Tianjin, pp. 109–11. (in Mandarin Chinese).
- Nei Menggu – Inner Mongolian numismatics (1992): Pl. 16. (in Mandarin Chinese).
- Ulrich Theobald (13 April 2016). "Qing Period Paper Money". Chinaknowledge.de. Retrieved 27 March 2019.
- Wei Jianyou (魏建猷) (1986) Zhongguo jindai huobisi (中國近代貨幣史). Huangshan shushechuban, p. 83. (in Mandarin Chinese).
- Peng Xinwei (彭信威) (1958) [rev. 1970, 1988, 2007] Zhongguo huobishi (中國貨幤史). Shanghai renmin chubanshe, Shanghai, pp. 556–559. (in Mandarin Chinese).
- Lin Man-houng (2006) China upside down: currency, society and ideologies. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts, pp 1808–1856, pp. 36–37.
- Hou Houji (侯厚吉), Wu Qijing (吴其敬) (1982) Zhongguo jindai jingji sixiang shigao (中國近代經濟思想史稿). Heilongjiang renminchubanshe, Harbin, vol. 1, p. 11. (in Mandarin Chinese).
- Nei Menggu qianbi yanjiu hui (內蒙古錢幣研究會), Zhongguo qianbi bianjibu (《中國錢幣》編輯部), ed. (1992); Cai Mingxin (蔡明信) (transl.). Zhongguo guchao tuji (Beijing: Zhongguo jinrong chubanshe). (in Mandarin Chinese).
- Horesh, N (2014) Chinese Money in Global Context: historic junctures between 600 BCE and 2012. Stanford University Press, Stanford.
- Cheng Linsun (2003) Banking in modern China: entrepreneurs, professional managers and the development of Chinese banks. Cambridge University Press, New York, pp 1897–1937
- Jerome Ch'ên (October 1958). "The Hsien-Fêng Inflation (Published online by Cambridge University Press: 24 December 2009)". SOAS University of London. Retrieved 28 July 2019.
- John E. Sandrock (1997). "IMPERIAL CHINESE CURRENCY OF THE TAI'PING REBELLION - Part II - CH'ING DYNASTY COPPER CASH NOTES by John E. Sandrock" (PDF). The Currency Collector. Retrieved 20 April 2019.
- Ulrich Theobald (10 May 2016). "Paper Money in Premodern China". Chinaknowledge. Retrieved 27 March 2019.
- John E. Sandrock (1997). "THE FOREIGN BANKS IN CHINA, PART I - EARLY IMPERIAL ISSUES (1850-1900) by John E. Sandrock - The Opening of China to the Outside World" (PDF). The Currency Collector. Retrieved 1 April 2019.
- Shanxi Provincial Academy of Social Sciences, ed., Shanxi piaohao shiliao (山西票号史料) (Taiyuan: Shanxi jingji chubanshe, 1992), pp. 36-39. (in Mandarin Chinese).
- John E. Sandrock (1997). "IMPERIAL CHINESE CURRENCY OF THE TAI'PING REBELLION - PART III - CH'ING DYNASTY SILVER TAEL NOTES by John E. Sandrock" (PDF). The Currency Collector. Retrieved 29 June 2019.
- King 1965, p. 159.
- Zhengce yanjiu (清代財政策与貨幣政策研究) (Wuhan: Wuhan da xue chu ban she, 2008), pp. 638–639. (in Mandarin Chinese).
- Ulrich Theobald (24 November 2015). "qianzhuang 錢莊, private banks". Chinaknowledge.de. Retrieved 9 August 2019.
- Xian Ke (獻可) (1958) Jinbainianlai diguozhuyi zai Hua yinhang faxing zhibi gaikuang (近百年來帝國主義在華銀行發行紙幣概況) [a survey of banknote issuance by imperialist banks in China in the last century]. Shanghai renmin chubanshe, Shanghai. (in Mandarin Chinese)
- Rawski TG (1989) Economic growth in prewar China. University of California Press, Berkeley.
- McElderry 1976, p. 21.
- Pan Liangui 2004, p. 105.
- McElderry 1976, p. 8–10.
- The First Modern Chinese Bank - the Imperial Bank of China
- No 6 THE RUSSELL BUILDING - SHANGHAI
- Fenerwerker, Albert - The Chinese Economy, 1870-1911, Ann Arbor, Michigan 1969, Center of Chinese Studies, University of Michigan.
- Kann, Eduard - “Foreign Note-Issuing Banks in China”, Far Eastern Economic Review, Hong Kong, Vol. XXV, June 1957.
- Wang Yeh- chien [Wang Yejian] (王業鍵) (1981) Zhongguo jindai huobi yu yinhang de yanjin (1644–1937) (中國近代貨幣與銀行的演進) (1644–1937). Academia Sinica, Taipei. (in. Mandarin Chinese).
- Hao Yen-p’ing (1986) The commercial revolution in nineteenth-century China. University of California Press, Berkeley, pp. 47–50.
- Yum Liu (August 2013). "A City of Commerce and its Native Banks: Hankou Qianzhuang (1800s-1952)". ResearchGate. Retrieved 17 August 2019.
- Wagel, S.S. (1915) Chinese currency and banking. North China Daily News and Herald, Shanghai p. 83.
- Hall Ray Ovid (1921) Chinese national banks: from their founding to the moratorium. s.n, Berlin, Germany. Pages 20–23.
- Faure, D. (2000) The Mackay treaty of 1902 and its impact on Chinese business. Asia Pacific Business Review (Asia Pac Bus Rev). Publisher: Taylor & Francis (Routledge), pages: 7(2):79–92.
- Hou Houji (侯厚吉), Wu Qijing (吴其敬) (1982) Zhongguo jindai jingji sixiang shigao (中國近代經濟思想史稿). Heilongjiang renminchubanshe, Harbin, vol. 3, pp. 322–339. (in Mandarin Chinese).
- Bruce, Colin - Standard Catalog of World Paper Money, Volume 1, Iola, Wisconsin 2005, Krause Publications.
- John E. Sandrock (1997). "FOREIGN BANKS IN CHINA, Part II - IMPERIAL CHINESE ISSUES (1900-1911) by John E. Sandrock" (PDF). The Currency Collector. Retrieved 10 April 2019.
- Feuerwerker, A. (1958) China’s early industrialization: sheng Hsuan-huai (1844–1916) and the mandarin enterprise. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
- Niv Horesh (2009) Shanghai's Bund and Beyond: British Banks, Banknote Issuance, and Monetary Policy in China, 1842–1937. Yale University Press, New Haven, Connecticut.
- Ji, Zhaojin - A History of Modern Shanghai Banking, London, 2003, M.E. Sharpe, Inc.
- "Foreign Note-Issuing Banks in China", Far Eastern Economic Review, Hong Kong, Vol. XXV, June 1957.
- Huang Jianhui 1994, p. 100–104.
- The Yokohama Specie Bank Building – built in 1924 (No. 24, The Bund) Archived 12 September 2011 at the Wayback Machine
- Davis, Clarence B.; Wilburn, Kenneth E., Jr; Robinson, Ronald E. (1991). "Russia, the Soviet Union, and the Chinese Eastern Railway". Railway Imperialism. Westport, Connecticut: Greenwood Press. p. 140. ISBN 9780313259661. Retrieved 24 July 2015 – via Questia.
- Issue in focus: Russian Bankers to Return to U.S. West Coast Archived 2007-08-16 at the Wayback Machine
- Watson, D.R. (January 1993). "The Rise and Fall of the Russo-Asiatic Bank. Problems of a Russian Enterprise with French Shareholders, 1910-26". doi:10.1177/026569149302300102. Cite journal requires
- Mihailoff, I. A. - North Manchurian and Chinese Eastern Railway, Harbin, China, 1924, C.E.R. Printing Office.
- Keller, Arnold - Das Papiergeld der Deutsches Kolonien, Münster, West Germany, 1967, Numismaticscher Verlag H. Dombrowski. (in German).
- Peng 1988, p. 886–889.
- Helleiner 2003, p. 38.
- Dai Zhiqiang (戴志強), ed. (2008). Zhongguo qianbi shoucang jianshang quanji (中國錢幣收藏鑒賞全集) (Changchun: Jilin chuban jituan). (in Mandarin Chinese).
- Feuerwerker, A. (1958) China’s early industrialization: sheng Hsuan-huai (1844–1916) and the mandarin enterprise. Publisher: Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
- Gabrisch, Karl (1990). Geld aus Tibet: Sammlung Dr. Karl Gabrisch; Ausstellung des Münzkabinetts der Stadt Winterthur (Winterthur: Departement für Kulturelles; Rikon: Tibet-Institut). (in German).
- Helleiner, E. (2003) The making of National Money: territorial currencies in historical perspective. Cornell University Press, Ithaca, New York.
- Huang Jianhui (黃鑒暉) (1994) Zhongguo yinhangyeshi (中國銀行業史). Shanxi jingji chubanshe, Taiyuan. (in Mandarin Chinese).
- Meng Pengxing (孟彭興) (1998). "Cong feiqian dao jiaozi huizi (從“飛錢”到“交子”、“會子”), in Zhang Dainian (張岱年), ed. Zhongguo wenshi baike (中國文史百科) (Hangzhou: Zhejiang renmin chubanshe), Vol. 1, 414. (in Mandarin Chinese).
- Pan Liangui (潘連貴) (2004) Shanghai huobishi (上海貨幣史). Shanghai renminchubanshe, Shanghai. (in Mandarin Chinese).
- Peng Xinwei (彭信威) (1954 ). Zhongguo huobi shi (中國貨幣史) (Shanghai: Qunlian chubanshe), 580-581, 597-605. (in Mandarin Chinese).
- Peng Xinwei (彭信威) (1994) A monetary history of China (translated by Edward H. Kaplan). Western Washington University (Bellingham, Washington).
- Xie Tianyu (謝天宇), ed. (2005). Zhongguo qianbi shoucang yu jianshang quanshu (中國錢幣收藏與鑒賞全書) (Tianjin: Tianjin guji chubanshe), Vol. 2, 508. (in Mandarin Chinese).
- Zhou Fazeng (周發增), Chen Longtao (陳隆濤), Qi Jixiang (齊吉祥), ed. (1998). Zhongguo gudai zhengzhi zhidu shi cidian (中國古代政治制度史辭典) (Beijing: Shoudu shifan daxue chubanshe), Pages 372, 375, 380, 381, 382. (in Mandarin Chinese).
|Wikimedia Commons has media related to Banknotes of the Qing dynasty.|