World Chess Championship 1910 (Lasker–Schlechter)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Emanuel Lasker faced Carl Schlechter in the 1910 World Chess Championship. It was played from January 7 to February 10, 1910 in Vienna and Berlin. The match was tied and Lasker retained his title.

Match conditions[edit]

Was it a championship match?[edit]

The match is generally regarded as a World Championship match, but some sources have doubted this in view of its strange outcome. R.J. Buckley reported in the American Chess Bulletin that the ten-game match was not for the World Championship, and that its result suggested that "a contest on different terms, a match for the World Championship" should be played. But at the foot of this article the editor added that Lasker had told him, "Yes, I placed the title at stake".[1] In the Encyclopaedia of Chess, Anne Sunnucks describes the match as "a so-called championship match".[2]

On the other hand, in its book Le guide des échecs the chess author Nicolas Giffard does not express the slightest doubt that this was a chess championship, but points out that in case Schlechter won, he would still need to win a revenge match before being called the World Champion.[3]

Was there a two-point margin clause?[edit]

Lasker drew the match by winning the final game. Many commentators have puzzled over Schlechter's play in this final game, in which he appeared to eschew the chance of a draw, and played for a win.

A common explanation is that Schlechter had to win by two points to win the world title. Israel Horowitz, Nicolas Giffard and Fred Wilson all write that a two-point margin was required.[3][4][5]

There appears to be no direct evidence for this. However, a two point margin for a 30 game match (as opposed to the 10 game match which was finally played) was agreed upon in 1908: "Conditions of the match with Schlechter have been agreed upon. Accordingly, it will consist of thirty games. Schlechter will win the championship of the world, if his score exceeds mine by two points at least. If the difference between the scores is only one point, the match will be a draw, and a tie match will have to be arranged."[6]

Possibly contradicting this, Lasker himself wrote two days before the tenth game, in his report to the New York Evening Post, "The match with Schlechter is nearing its end and it appears probable that for the first time in my life I shall be the loser. If that should happen a good man will have won the World Championship",[7] which could imply that it really was a world title match and that there was no secret "two-game lead" clause.

Other explanations have been advanced for the development of the last game. A report shortly after the end of the match appears to speculate that Schlechter threw the last game because a narrow victory for him would not have been in the financial interests of either player, as they would have had to play another match if Schlechter won narrowly, but they had not been able to get adequate financial backing for the 1910 match.[8]

Another interpretation, offered separately by Luděk Pachman and Larry Evans, is that Schlechter simply did not play the final game well. Pachman writes, "both players were labouring under such nervous stress that their power of judgment was not working as well as it normally did."[9] Evans writes, "The truth is Schlechter probably never saw a clear draw! He missed 35...Rd8! with good winning chances. Later he said he intended 38...Qh4 39 Kg2 Qg4 40 Rg3 Qxc8 overlooking 41 Qg6! Flustered, he then missed a draw – and the title – by 39...Qh4! 40 Kd2 Qh2 41 Ke3 Rxf3 42 Kxf3 Qh3 43 Ke2 Qxc8 44 Qxb5, etc. The last hope to hold was 46...Qa2."[7]

Another suggestion is that Schlechter played to win the last game because he was too honourable to get the title by a fluke, having won the fifth game when Lasker blundered in a better position.[10]

Results[edit]

The match was best of 10 games. The match was drawn, so Lasker retained the world title.

World Chess Championship Match 1910
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Points
 Carl Schlechter (Austria-Hungary) ½ ½ ½ ½ 1 ½ ½ ½ ½ 0 5
 Emanuel Lasker (Germany) ½ ½ ½ ½ 0 ½ ½ ½ ½ 1 5

Popular culture[edit]

A fictionalised account of the match is presented in the 1998 novel Carl Haffner's Love of the Draw by Thomas Glavinic.

Footnotes[edit]

  1. ^ Buckley, R.J. (June 1910), "Who was R.J. Buckley? by Edward Winter", American Chess Bulletin, retrieved 2008-05-30
  2. ^ Sunnucks 1970.
  3. ^ a b Giffard 1993, p. 404.
  4. ^ Horowitz 1973, p. 64.
  5. ^ Wilson 1975
  6. ^ "Lasker-Schlechter Chess", Emanuel Lasker, New York Evening Post, 23 December 1908, page 5. Cited in The Lasker v Schlechter Controversy (1910), Edward Winter, 16 July 2019
  7. ^ a b Righting Two Wrongs, Larry Evans, worldchessnetwork.com, October 28, 2002.
  8. ^ Walter Preiswerk (20 February 1910), "(title unknown)", Basler Nachrichten, retrieved 2008-07-10 – scroll down to Chess Note 4144 "Lasker v Schlechter"
  9. ^ Pachman 1987, pp. 48–51.
  10. ^ Keene, Raymond (1 March 2000). "Was Schlechter Robbed?". MindZine. Archived from the original on 5 December 2008. Retrieved 20 September 2019.

External links[edit]

Lasker-Schlechter Game 10, chessgames.com

References[edit]