clock menu more-arrow no yes

NYC Subway Needs $1.7 Billion In New Elevators, Feds Say

New, 13 comments

The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) became law in 1990 and now, a quarter century later, the federal government—specifically the Federal Transit Administration—wants the MTA to make more of its 469 subway stations accessible. The FTA has recommended adding more elevators, which could mean an additional $1.7 billion expense, according to the Wall Street Journal.

Right now, only 22 percent of the stations are accessible. Compare that to San Francisco's BART system, which is 100 percent accessible (but has far fewer stations than the New York City subway), or Chicago's transit system, which has 145 stations, more than half of which are accessible.

On top of that, the MTA's previous efforts at accessibility may have been a mistake. Instead of adding elevators throughout the subway system, which are both costly and complicated to install, the MTA focused on making buses accessible (they all now accommodate wheelchairs) and adding paratransit automobile rides for the disabled. "It turns out that was a horrendously bad decision," Howard Roberts, who used to run NYC's transit system, told the WSJ. "It probably has turned out to be…100 times more expensive to go with buses and paratransit than it would have been to bite the bullet and simply rehabilitate the stations and put elevators in."

Under the current MTA plan, the number of stations with elevators will go from 111 to 144 by 2020, but the feds are pushing for more. WSJ reports there has been suggestion that subway station staircase repairs should be accompanied by elevator installation, a suggestion the MTA has not taken kindly to. All of this makes the MTA's budget situation even more precarious, as the agency's slightly trimmed $26 billion capital plan is already in limbo.
· MTA Under Pressure to Add Elevators to More Subway Stations [WSJ]
· MTA's $29B Capital Plan Cuts Second Ave Subway Funds in Half [Curbed]
· All MTA coverage [Curbed]