James Fenimore Cooper
James Fenimore Cooper, like Irving, evoked a sense of the past
and gave it a local habitation and a name. In Cooper, though, one
finds the powerful myth of a golden age and the poignance of its
loss. While Irving and other American writers before and after
him scoured Europe in search of its legends, castles, and great
themes, Cooper grasped the essential myth of America: that it was
timeless, like the wilderness. American history was a trespass on
the eternal; European history in America was a reenactment of the
fall in the Garden of Eden. The cyclical realm of nature was
glimpsed only in the act of destroying it: The wilderness
disappeared in front of American eyes, vanishing before the
oncoming pioneers like a mirage. This is Cooper's basic tragic
vision of the ironic destruction of the wilderness, the new Eden
that had attracted the colonists in the first place.
Personal experience enabled Cooper to write vividly of the
transformation of the wilderness and of other subjects such as
the sea and the clash of peoples from different cultures. The son
of a Quaker family, he grew up on his father's remote estate at
Otsego Lake (now Cooperstown) in central New York State.
Although this area was relatively peaceful during Cooper's
boyhood, it had once been the scene of an Indian massacre. Young
Fenimore Cooper grew up in an almost feudal environment. His
father, Judge Cooper, was a landowner and leader. Cooper saw
frontiersmen and Indians at Otsego Lake as a boy; in later life,
bold white settlers intruded on his land.
Natty Bumppo, Cooper's renowned literary character, embodies his vision of the frontiersman as a gentleman, a Jeffersonian "natural aristocrat." Early in 1823, in The Pioneers, Cooper had begun to discover Bumppo. Natty is the first famous frontiersman in American literature and the literary forerunner of countless cowboy and backwoods heroes. He is the idealized, upright individualist who is better than the society he protects. Poor and isolated, yet pure, he is a touchstone for ethical values and prefigures Herman Melville's Billy Budd and Mark Twain's Huck Finn.
Based in part on the real life of American pioneer Daniel Boone -- who was a Quaker like Cooper -- Natty Bumppo, an outstanding woodsman like Boone, was a peaceful man adopted by an Indian tribe. Both Boone and the fictional Bumppo loved nature and freedom. They constantly kept moving west to escape the oncoming settlers they had guided into the wilderness, and they became legends in their own lifetimes. Natty is also chaste, high-minded, and deeply spiritual: He is the Christian knight of medieval romances transposed to the virgin forest and rocky soil of America.
The unifying thread of the five novels collectively known as the Leather-Stocking Tales is the life of Natty Bumppo. Cooper's finest achievement, they constitute a vast prose epic with the North American continent as setting, Indian tribes as characters, and great wars and westward migration as social background. The novels bring to life frontier America from 1740 to 1804.
Cooper's novels portray the successive waves of the frontier settlement: the original wilderness inhabited by Indians; the arrival of the first whites as scouts, soldiers, traders, and frontiersmen; the coming of the poor, rough settler families; and the final arrival of the middle class, bringing the first professionals -- the judge, the physician, and the banker. Each incoming wave displaced the earlier: Whites displaced the Indians, who retreated westward; the "civilized" middle classes who erected schools, churches, and jails displaced the lower- class individualistic frontier folk, who moved further west, in turn displacing the Indians who had preceded them. Cooper evokes the endless, inevitable wave of settlers, seeing not only the gains but the losses.
Cooper's novels reveal a deep tension between the lone individual and society, nature and culture, spirituality and organized religion. In Cooper, the natural world and the Indian are fundamentally good -- as is the highly civilized realm associated with his most cultured characters. Intermediate characters are often suspect, especially greedy, poor white settlers who are too uneducated or unrefined to appreciate nature or culture. Like Rudyard Kipling, E.M. Forster, Herman Melville, and other sensitive observers of widely varied cultures interacting with each other, Cooper was a cultural relativist. He understood that no culture had a monopoly on virtue or refinement.
Cooper accepted the American condition while Irving did not. Irving addressed the American setting as a European might have -- by importing and adapting European legends, culture, and history. Cooper took the process a step farther. He created American settings and new, distinctively American characters and themes. He was the first to sound the recurring tragic note in American fiction.
